Sketches of Spain, Part 3 – Granada & Madrid

Last month my wife, Kelly, and I embarked on the “Two Weeks in Spain” so famed in song.  It was a wonderful trip and impossible to convey all we were able to do and see, but over the next few posts I wanted to share a little bit of what made the journey so special. Each post has musical accompaniment, so press “play” at the bottom and enjoy.

Granada

At one point I said that Cordoba reminded me of New Orleans – old city surrounded by modern  big city – with the topography of Morgantown – lots of hills. If that’s accurate then Granada could be described similarly, but with the topography of Logan – an old town built in a valley with steep hills on either side.

On one hill is the Alhambra, perhaps the go-to example of “Moorish buildings in Spain” in the minds of most people. More of that later, but after we arrived in town (via another drive through the countryside) and had some lunch, we decided to trek up the other hill, into a neighborhood called the Albaicín, which is where the original city was founded.

And those weren’t the steepest ones!

It was a haul, but the view was great.

View from a wall, looking over at the Alhambra.
High altitude selfie.

The Albaicín was where, during the early days of the Spanish Civil War, the Republicans made their resistance, using the narrow streets and hills as natural fortifications. Alas, the Fascists just moved artily into the Alhambra and shelled them into surrender.

Our main goal for that evening, though, was something I’d been trying to set up since before COVID hit – seeing a soccer game in Europe. We tried to go see Leeds play during our UK trip a few years back, but couldn’t get tickets (and a one-day rail strike changed our plans, anyway). When we knew where we were going in Spain I dove into finding a place to watch a game. In the end, the only place where that could work out was in Granada.

Granada CF, which dates back to 1931, currently plays in the Spanish second division, but were in La Liga as recently as 2023-2024. Their colors are red, white, and blue, which seemed appropriate, even if the resulting kit feels very FC Dallas at times.

Good seats!

“Granada,” as well as being the name of the city, is also Spanish for “pomegranate” (although the word origins are different), which explains the club’s sentient pomegranate mascot, Granain:

You, too, will have nightmares.

The stadium was about the size of a modern MLS stadium and was probably two-thirds full. The local supporters group, behind one goal, were pretty vocal and the rest of the crowd got into it fairly often. We really hated the right back from Real Valladolid for some reason, but we joined in booing him every time he touched the ball.

First half action.

The ball came into our area of the stands twice. Once a guy sitting behind Kelly fumbled it into the seat next to her, spilling our popcorn. A fan down the row tossed us his to make up for it (I noted later that he had a backpack full of snacks – apparently they don’t care so much about bringing your own stuff into a game). The second time a guy sitting in front of me calmly stood up and headed the ball back onto the pitch. Best header of the night!

Ultimately, the good guys won 2-1 – so I now have a team in Spain to root for!

For while, though, I thought we’d never make it back to the hotel. A map on the city website said there was a taxi stand right at the corner of the block where the stadium was. Alas, there was none. Two helpful fans leaving the game explained that they block off the streets before the game lets out so the cabs stay away. They pointed us to a spot a couple of blocks down to try. That didn’t really work and we couldn’t get the local cab app to work, either. We relocated again, about another block away, and finally got lucky. For a while there I thought we were walking home (45 minutes, per Google) in the dark in a foreign city. Whew!

The next morning, it was on to the Alhambra.

Sort of. There’s a lot to the place, so we actually started with the Generalife, a more modern palace and grounds with, as damned near everywhere in Granada, brilliant views.

Garden in the Generalife.
That view.

It’s nice, but hardly the main attraction.

That said, the Alhambra is not a building, so much as it is a collection of them. It was once, essentially, its own city. So in addition to defensive walls and such it’s got a cathedral, a former convent, and an unfinished palace that (hundreds of years later) became a museum.

So, naturally you had to have water for the place – so a Roman-era aqueduct did the trick (bringing water from the source of the river up in the mountains).

What have the Romans ever done for us?
Walkway flanked by shrubberies on either side.
The former convent, now a hotel.
Another view of the former convent.

There are still a few people who actually live in the Alhambra and many who work there, with a street of shops open on the walk down to the main attraction.

Kelly headed downhill.

Primarily, of course, the Alhambra was a fortress.

Towers and turrets.
Barracks, excavated down to the foundation.
Entrance to the dungeon (there ain’t no steps in there, neither).

You don’t build on the high ground for nothing.

The more modern part of the city, with the cathedral.
The Albaicín. I think the bare spot there just right of center is where we hiked to the day before.

But it was also a very elaborate palace.

Vaulted, carved ceiling.
Every room with a view!
Our guide explained that, by some 20th-century proof, there’s a certain (pretty big) number of variants on this kind of design – this place has all of them.
A not great picture of a really beautiful courtyard.
Better picture, lesser courtyard.
Ceiling painting.
Ceiling with a very stalactite-like finish.

The most famous part of the place is the Court of the Lions, which includes this spectacular fountain.

The fountain through columns.
From the other side.

In true Tufnel fashion, nobody really knows why they were built or what they’re supposed to represent. Each one is unique, though, which shows the amount of time it took to build them all (in the 14th century).

The place isn’t just ancient. Charles V, Holy Roman Emperor and King of Spain, started building a palace here in 1527, but it went unfinished and was abandoned in 1637 (well after his death). It was finally “completed” in 1927, but only got a roof in 1967. There’s a metaphor in there somewhere. Nice courtyard, though.

Lots of square footage, but how much is usable?

We spent the afternoon exploring the city.

A waterfall on the way down the hill from the Alhambra.
Washington Irving, who wrote “Tales from the Alhambra” after coming to Granada on diplomatic duty.
For my guitar playing friends and relations.

We stopped at the Casa de Zafra, a restored home that serves as a museum of the Albaicín.

Courtyard.
Yet again, an amazing view (of . . . c’mon, guess!).

Stumbled into some street flamenco.

Have dance, will travel.

And a little torture, at the Museo de Olvidados (the “museum of the forgotten”), filled with toys from the Inquisition.

Doesn’t get much worse than a metal pig mask.
The street outside our hotel at dusk. It’s narrower than it looks!

Madrid

We really only went back to Madrid because it was the best place to fly home from. Nonetheless, it was a good excuse for another good dinner at a local place and one last batch of churros!

One (or two . . . or ten) for the road.

A word about . . . language.

I will admit – I was a little skeptical we’d be able to wade through this trip given that neither of us actually speak Spanish. When we went to Cambodia we had guides/translators with us the whole time and when we went to the UK, well they speak English (basically). Thankfully, most of the folks we dealt with had enough English proficiency that we could communicate well enough. It was a little more stressful in, say, train stations, were most announcement were in Spanish only, but day-to-day, we got along pretty well. A large part of that is down to the kindness of the Spanish people we dealt with (aside from the graffiti artists in Madrid).

Take it away . . . Joaquín (and friends)

After a few riffs on the original, here it is in all its glory, Joaquín Rodrigo’s Concecierto de Aranjuez.

And because I can’t resist finishing up with the prog, Emerson, Lake, & Palmer send us off with “Canario,” an adaptation of another Rodrigo piece (which is excellent – ignore the horrific fashion choices).

Sketches of Spain, Part 2 – Seville & Malaga

Last month my wife, Kelly, and I embarked on the “Two Weeks in Spain” so famed in song.  It was a wonderful trip and impossible to convey all we were able to do and see, but over the next few posts I wanted to share a little bit of what made the journey so special. Each post has musical accompaniment, so press “play” at the bottom and enjoy.

Seville

A short train ride and we were in Seville (no barbers in sight!).

Our hotel in Malaga was . . . odd. For one thing, it wasn’t a single building, but a bunch of old homes all tied together into a hotel. As a result we had to take a tunnel (and about three elevators) to get to our room.

Kelly, hoping this doesn’t turn into some kind if “Shining” situation.

And, well, this was awkward.

Excuse me . . .

Our hotel (of which more later) was deep in the old town and, as in Cordoba, we set off to explore a bit before dinner.

When we left the hotel there was a crowd starting to gather and what looked like a community band milling around in the street. By the time we got back the crowd was so thick we couldn’t actually reach our hotel. Turns out it was just a few doors down from Iglesia de Santa Maria la Blanca and it was about time for a processional.

Numerous Catholic guys waiting on the thing to get rolling.

It took a while for the whole coterie to make its way out of the church, but the ending was worth it.

A very elaborate float (?) with Mary and lots of candles.

I later asked someone at the hotel how often that kind of thing happened (it was Sunday, after all) and apparently it’s not super common, but not really rare, either. While we were there we saw some posters for other similar events for different saints.

The next day we dove into the history of Seville with a tour that included both the local palace, the Real Alcazar (still used, occasionally, by the Spanish royal family) and the cathedral. The Alcazar has a lot of fascinating history – it was through here that most of the wealth of the Spanish empire in the Americas came into the country (and was taxed). It’s also got some interesting architecture, blending styles from various cultures.

Main courtyard, with a different-era palace on each of three sides.
Big glass skylight on the first palace, built by a Christian king with lots of Muslim influences.
A reception hall in the main palace.

My favorite detail were these balconies, installed by Pietro I, which are, in fact, fake:

The ceiling is designed to represent the cosmos – with mirrors at the center to reflect the king at the center.

The idea was to impress visitors with the possibility of rooms on a higher level. Potemkin balconies – who’d have thunk it?

An interior courtyard, meant to depict the Muslim idea of paradise (a gift from the calif, with whom the king was good friends).

Another lovely detail – this is a confessional chapel built right outside the big room next door where the king held lavish parties. I correctly guessed was that the idea was to go inside, sin your brains out, then come out here to repent.

Sin. Repent. Repeat.
A tapestry in the very swanky party room.

As a good palace does, there were gardens, too.

Kelly in the garden.
A peacock (peahen? peabeing?) being photogenic in the gardens.

The cathedral, well, it was amazing. Completed in 1519 it’s the largest Gothic cathedral in the world and the third largest of any kind on the planet.

Outside the cathedral.
Vaults upon vaults (with stained glass).
Stained glass and paintings.
Another choir loft (I think).

Indeed, the altar is the largest in the world – the Vatican has a scale copy (quite the flex).

So large it’s hard to get a good picture!

Among the many people interred in the cathedral are a pair of Columbuses (Columbi?), Christopher and his second son, Ferdinand. Christopher, as you might expect, has a pretty elaborate tomb:

The remains of Christopher Columbus (probably) – at least 80% of him.

Whether that’s actually him in there has subject to some debate (his remains moved around a lot after his death), but appears to be settled now thanks to DNA comparisons with his son. Ferdinand, on the other hand, gets a respectful tile over his grave in the floor.

Columbus’ son, a man rich in books (and other things).

Ferdinand lacked the accomplishments of his father, but he was rich and, in particular, had an extensive library. He guaranteed his resting place in the cathedral by agreeing to give the church his collection upon his death. It’s still available to researchers.

Part of the cathedral is the Giralda, a tower that was once the minaret for the mosque on the site and is now the bell tower for the cathedral. We climbed up all 37 ramps (instead of stairs, allegedly so the muezzin back in the day could ride a burro to the top to do the call to prayer), which provided some great views of the city.

The Giralda at night.

Still a long way up, though!

That night we had a cool experience, a combination tapas walking tour and flamenco experience. Our guide – a very outgoing French expat named Remy – led us from bar to bar for some food and wine, all the while explaining the history and basics of flamenco. Then, a flamenco show:

The two dancers.

I didn’t realize going in how improvisational these were. I assumed there was some choreography, moves that went with certain songs, what have you. As explained by Remy, and as evident from the performance, it’s very free flowing and in the moment. I particularly enjoyed when one dancer just kind of kept going past where the guitarist and vocalists thought was the end and they wound up pushing to a very joyful end. The guitar player was a fucking beast, by the way.

The entire ensemble (including two vocalists).

The next day (we spent three nights in Seville) was very low key, with a bath and spa time in the morning and a cruise on the “river” (actually a canal that follows the original course of the river) as a means to see some more of the city.

Another in my long-running series of “pictures of Kelly taking pictures of things,” in this case a fountain whose name I can’t recollect.

The spa/bath experience was interesting. Massages don’t do much for me (Kelly loves them) and I wind up feeling awkward and tense rather than relaxed. The baths, however, were nice. One set was divided into hot/warm/cold zones, while another was, essentially a giant jacuzzi. I split my time between those two, for the most part. We were supposed to have an additional bath experience in their rooftop pool, but it was down for maintenance (I think it would have been too cold, but whatever). As compensation, we were given a wine bath – a huge tub filled with wine. In which we sat. And drank wine (and nibbled on cheese and crackers). If ever there is a “this is what it feels just before the peasants revolt” setting, that was it.

Malaga

Rather than take the train, we hired a car to make it to Malaga (the train schedules just didn’t work out, for whatever reason). It was a nice change of pace, literally, and gave us a chance to take in some of the landscape. This part of Spain is pretty dry and not particularly lush. It is covered all over with olive trees, however (Spain, apparently, is the largest producer of olive oil in the world – and it’s quite tasty!). Nearer to the coast it got mountainous, which made me think a bit of home, which was nice.

Malaga had a unique feature in terms of its old town, a fairly intact Roman-era theater.

Roman theater, with the Alcazaba on the hill in the background.

You can sit in the stone bleachers and imagine someone taking in the latest work by Seneca or Gaius Maecenas Melissus and complaining, “I’ve seen it before.”

Could definitely fling produce at the stage from this distance.

Up the hill is the Alcazaba, a fortress dating back to the 11th Century. It’s laid on hill so it really clings to the landscape (like Obert’s house in Gods of the Empire, if you’re familiar).

Kelly beside the outer wall.
Towers in various states of decay.
Garden with fountain.

It does provide some great views of the city, particularly the harbor.

A view from a hill (as the song goes) – I think the big circular thing is a bullring.
Kelly, with the harbor in the background.

We decided not to hike all the way to the top of the hill, to the Gibralfaro castle. Gotta know your limits.

The main reason we went to Malaga was Picasso. He was born there and there’s a museum dedicated to him there.

Music while we waited to get in.

It’s pretty well done, covering the breadth of his artistic output.

“Bather”
“Flute Player”

I liked his take on art: “We all know that art is not truth. Art is a lie that makes us realize the truth.”

Kelly’s favorite – “Man Looking at a Sleeping Woman”
My favorite – “Reclining Nude and Cat”

That said, a lot of his more well-known stuff is elsewhere (such as the Reina Sofia in Madrid). And the museum steered clear of Picasso’s personal life. A little post-visit digging shows why, as he was pretty much a monster to those around him.

The other reason we went to Malaga was to get a little sense of the Mediterranean coast. We didn’t really “go to the beach,” but we did walk down and breathe in some salt air (Kelly waded in a bit – the water was cold). It’s very pretty.

Kelly wades.

We wound up on this spit that juts out into the bay.

Big damned fishing poles.
Selfie in the sun.

With that, we were off to Granada . . .

A word about . . . transport.

I’ve mentioned taking trains or cars to get around while we were in Spain, but I wanted to say a couple of things about transport in general. For one, the high-speed trains are amazing. The one we took from Madrid to Cordoba almost hit 300 kph, which is more than 180 mph. That’s absolutely hauling ass. Of course, when things go wrong at that speed they really go wrong, as evidenced by the horrific crash on that line a few days after we got back. And, it has to be said, none of our trains left on time. Cabs were useful in the cities, even if sometimes it was hard to find one (as you’ll see in Granada).

Take it away . . . Chick

Another jazz exploration of some of the themes from Joaquín Rodrigo’s Concecierto de Aranjuez. Originally recorded by Return to Forever, I thought this live version from years later with Chick’s band hit the spot.

Sketches of Spain, Part 1 – Madrid & Cordoba

Last month my wife, Kelly, and I embarked on the “Two Weeks in Spain” so famed in song.  It was a wonderful trip and impossible to convey all we were able to do and see, but over the next few posts I wanted to share a little bit of what made the journey so special. Each post has musical accompaniment, so press “play” at the bottom and enjoy.

Departure

Naturally, I had to check in with Señor Foot on the way out of town, at our local “international” airport.

Checking in with our local cryptid on the way out.

The flights were, thankfully, uneventful and resulted in only a minor amount of panic from me (I’m not a good flyer).

Madrid

Our first stop was Madrid, where we would stay for a couple of nights before heading off into Andalusia, where we spent the bulk of our days. We landed around noon local time, which felt much later due to jet lag. Instead of falling into bed, we decided to push on through dinnertime and try to adapt to the time change.

Our hotel was right downtown, near a busy traffic circle and a park frequently used for protests. There was a McDonald’s on the corner (although Burger King seemed more prevalent overall), but we bypassed a taste of home and headed for the Plaza Mayor.

Plaza del Mayor. The guy on the horse is Felipe III.

The plaza is ringed by restaurants and tourist trap shops, but Kelly had a different destination in mind. We walked through the square, down a set of stairs and an alley, and had our first experience with Spanish cuisine – churros con chocolate!

Yes, they’re even better than they look.

The place, San Gines, struck me as the Spanish version of Cafe du Monde in New Orleans – they basically do one thing, but they do it very well. That thing is fresh, crispy churros (no cinnamon, like we get here), served with a cup of drinking chocolate (think hot chocolate that aspires to be mousse). The chocolate clings onto the churros when dipped and makes an irresistible combination.

On our way back to the square, I was heckled! I was wearing my Leeds jersey, not knowing that Manchester United had been in Madrid the night before getting beaten by Atletico in the Champions League. A grieving Mancunian saw my jersey and called me out (among other things, as “Yorkshire scum”!), but I just laughed it off.

It was a little harder to laugh off what we found at the Plaza de Sol.

Tent city protest that had been going on for several weeks (and caused the Prime Minister to call for new elections).

A long-term protest camp had been erected there. The prime motivation is the housing affordability crisis in Spain (it’s led to the prime minister calling for a new election), but has embraced a hodge podge of grievances, one of which was, well, us – someone had spray painted “tourists go home!” on the plinth of a monument. Graffiti aside, nobody said or did anything to us as we took in the scene. Heck of a way to orient to your surroundings, though.

For our only full day in Madrid our focus was on art. Our hotel was just down the street from the Prado, which is where we spent a good chunk of our day.

Kelly in front of the Prado. That’s a statue of Velazquez behind her.
A statue of Goya outside the Prado.

The Prado is, of course, full of amazing art (none of which you can take pictures of, unfortunately). It’s collection is fairly narrow, though, focusing largely on Spanish artists from a few-century slice of time. Lots of portraits of dead rich people and more saints and crucifixions than you can shake a stick at.

My two favorite chunks involved more disturbing images. The Prado has a large collection of works by Hieronymus Bosch, who specialized in surreal religious imagery. This includes his famous tryptic, The Garden of Earthly Delights:

Taken from Wikipedia

I particularly liked this owl, who’s face is just like “what the hell have I gotten myself into?”

We’ve all been there, dude.

The Seven Deadly Sins and the Four Last Things is pretty striking, too:

Imagine sitting down to this to play a game of bridge.

The other collection that really struck me are the so-called “Black Paintings” by Goya. They were painted on the walls of his home later in his life and, perhaps, were never intended to be shown to the public. As the name suggests they’re dark and you can feel creeping mortality clinging to them. The most famous of them:

Saturn devouring his son.

The Black Paintings inspired some musical ideas and a story idea, too, so I suspect I’ll return to them over and over in the future.

That evening our focus turned more modern, as we spent some time at the Reina Sofia, which is dedicated to more modern art. It’s full of neat stuff by Picasso, Dali, Miro and others – precisely the stuff I love but that Kelly will roll her eyes at frequently. And they let you take pictures!

“Maternity” by Alberto
“Still Life” by Villa
“The Face of the Great Masturbator” by Dali (couldn’t resist)

The centerpiece of the collections is Picasso’s sprawling mural, Guernica.

“Guernica” by Picasso

It’s even more impactful in person, the black/grey/white palate evocative of the newspaper photographs that first brought the atrocity to the world’s attention.

Cordoba

The next morning we hopped a train to our first Andalusian destination – Cordoba.

Kelly on a Cordoba Street with the bell tower of the Mezquita in the background.

In a way, Cordoba set the template for the rest of our journey. It’s a city with ancient roots, defined by layers of overlapping cultures (Romans, Visigoths, Muslims, Christians) that produce a particular vibe in terms of what the place looks and smells like. It was also our first experience of the really narrow streets in the old town!

A very narrow street (one of many).

We spent the rest of that day walking the streets of the old town, down to the Puerta del Puente, a 16th-century gate to the city, and across the Roman Bridge – which mostly dates from the 8th century.

Kelly beholds the Puerta del Puente
The Roman Bridge with the old town in the background.
Selfie with bridge.

At the other end is the Calahorra Tower, a fortified gate first built in the 14th century. It provided some great views back across the river of the old town.

Yours truly in front of the Calahorra Tower.

Our major site to see in Cordoba was what’s commonly called the “Mezquita,” although technically it is the Mosque-Cathedral of Cordoba. It’s a place where all those layers really come to the fore. But before we made it there, we were shown some other spots from what’s known as the “Jewish Quarter” (even though the Jews were expelled from town in 1391).

Interior of the synagogue.
Statue of Maimonides (rabbi, physician, philosopher), born in Cordoba.

As I said, this led us to the Mezquita.

More arches than a McDonald’s convention!

The site was initially a Catholic church, built by the Visigoths, before it became a mosque after the Muslim conquest. Not just any mosque, either, but a massive one (perhaps the largest in the world at the time). After the Christians retook the city in the middle ages, rather than destroy the mosque and build a cathedral, they built the cathedral right in the middle of the place.

Hard to see, but mosaics from the original Visigoth construction under the current floor.

So you go from views like this, with row upon row of arches and columns:

More arches.
Yup, that’s Jesus.

And then turn the corner and BOOM – cathedral:

Transition into the cathedral space.
Choir stalls along with two massive organs.

It’s an amazing place and cell phone pictures hardly do it justice.

Stone-worker’s mark, “signing” his work hundreds of years ago.

We spent the rest of the day in the old town, popping in here and there.

Church in the Jewish Quarter with a 300-year-old palm tree in the courtyard (growing through the roof).
Bust of a matador famed for dying young in the bullring (so, a loser?).
Art from inside Calahorra Tower.

With that, we were off to Seville . . ..

A few words about . . . food (and wine)

We ate well in Spain. For the most part we didn’t seek out particular places, instead catching meals at small tabernas where we could sit outside and enjoy the city passing by. Kelly fell in love with salmorejo, a very garlic-forward chilled tomato soup (I didn’t think you could have too much garlic – I was wrong!), while my find of the trip was carrilladas or braised pork cheeks (super tender with a wonderful, hearty sauce). We drank very well, too, of course, never had a bad glass of wine (of which there were plenty). I was surprised how wine-focused the place was, to the point where there didn’t appear to be a lot of cocktails and you have the need for wine-bottle-specific trash cans outside a thousand-year old holy site!

Just the wine, now.

Take it away . . . Miles

Miles Davis did an album called Sketches of Spain that’s more orchestral and almost ambient in spots than other stuff I’ve heard of his. The big part of side one is a take on the Adagio movement of Joaquín Rodrigo’s Concecierto de Aranjuez, of which we’ll hear more later.

On Historical Fiction

Years ago – I mean years ago  – I remembered Roger Ebert describing Michael Bay’s Pearl Harbor in this withering way:

“Pearl Harbor” is a two-hour movie squeezed into three hours, about how on Dec. 7, 1941, the Japanese staged a surprise attack on an American love triangle.

At the time I thought that was just a good burn on a bad, schlocky, blockbuster (surely less entertaining than the commentary track for whichever Kevin Smith film it was where they bust on co-star Ben Affleck relentlessly for it), but the more I think about it, Ebert’s observation identifies a key difficulty when it comes to historical fiction – are you telling a story about a historical event or about people in a historical time who might be impacted by it?

That dilemma hit me recently as I read a pair of books built around a period of local history known as the West Virginia Mine Wars. They take very different approaches to the material which left one much more successful than the other, at least for me.

The first was Rednecks, by Taylor Brown.

“Rednecks,” for those not familiar, was the term used to describe striking miners who would tie a red bandana around their necks (it was derogatory at first, then adopted by the miners). The book Rednecks acts almost as a kind of sequel to the great John Sayles’ film Matewan, starting with the “Matewan Massacre” that was the culmination of the film. It then tells of the events that led to the Battle of Blair Mountain, the largest armed conflict in the United States since the Civil War (so far, at least).

The second book was Storming Heaven, by Denise Giardina.

While it ends in roughly the same place as Rednecks, Storming Heaven covers the whole of the Mine Wars period, starting with the railroads coming into the West Virginia/Kentucky border area in the 1890s and buying up property using sketchy methods.

Beyond that, the two books differ in whose story is being told. The main characters in Rednecks are a local doctor (of Lebanese extraction, apparently inspired by one of the author’s ancestors) and a miner, both fictional, but lots of the smaller roles are filled by real people – Mother Jones, Sid Hatfield, and such. We get chapters from their points-of-view and some big speeches that are probably historically accurate. The downside is that they tend to drain the momentum of the main characters’ stories and can come off like one of those “you are there!” books for young readers.

By contrast, in Storming Heaven all the characters are fictional. They do occasionally interact with real people and some are fictional takes on real people – Sid Hatfield, for instance, gets a doppelganger who is also assassinated on the courthouse steps. In fact, the book takes place in a couple of fictional counties (one in West Virginia, on in Kentucky), but manages to interact with the “real world” enough to retain a sense of realism.

The result is that Rednecks feels like a book that was written to bring knowledge of a particular historical event to the public via fiction. That’s a noble pursuit and it’s certainly a mode of fiction that does a lot of work across literature, film, and TV. What it doesn’t really feel like is a story of people, characters, who feel alive and real in their own. I was far more engaged with Rednecks when it focused on the fictional doc and miner than when it leaned on actual historical figures.

Storming Heaven, by contrast feels like a fully fleshed out work of fiction that happens to be set during a particular historical period. I didn’t care about the characters because of the events they were living through, I cared about them as individuals. In the process, I think you get a better feel for what the historical period was like. No doubt, Rednecks is a lot more granular in terms of how Blair Mountain went down, but Storming Heaven hits harder emotionally, even with less historical detail.

I did an interview recently where I said that the most important element in good writing is building interesting characters. If you don’t care about the people to whom the events of the story are happening nothing else really matters. I think details of events are better left to non-fiction, to the work of historians and journalists. Historical fiction works best when it’s trying to capture the feeling of what it meant to live during the time period involved.

Or you can do what I do and plunder history for ideas and turn them into fantasy or sci-fi stories. Then there’s no worry about getting history “right” because the history is whatever you think it should be!

How Censors Work

When I was first pulling together the world of the Unari Empire, one of the character ideas I had was that of an Imperial censor. That character would kind of pop up throughout the story, struggling to hold on as the Empire shattered around them, slowly losing their will to do the job that had defined them. I shelved that particular idea since I didn’t have a good handle on what the day-to-day life of a censor looked like.

If only I’d read Robert Darnton’s Censors at Work: How States Shaped Literature back then I might have given it a go.

Darnton explores the nitty gritty of how censors actually did their jobs during three historical periods – pre-Revolutionary France, India in the late 19th and early 20th centuries under British rule, and East Germany right around the fall of the Berlin Wall. It’s a dry work, without a lot of compelling through lines for casual readers, but it does offer some fascinating insights into what it means to be a “censor.”

Primarily, what censors did (or what these censors did) on a daily basis wasn’t squelch explicitly political speech aimed at criticizing the regime for which they worked. In a lot of ways they worked as hyper-powerful literary gatekeepers, helping to shape literature by acting as a kind of quality control. The French censors, many of whom were writers themselves, wanted to ensure the quality of French literature. The British censors in India were hopeful they could guide the Indians into writing great literature (“great” here meaning “what British thinkers consider great,” of course). The East Germans helped literary works get trimmed and massaged to reach an audience.

To an extent, in crafting these portraits, Darnton is trying to humanize the censors. They weren’t faceless thugs grinding ideas into the dirt under their bootheels – they were just people doing a job in which they believed, at least most of the time. This isn’t to say that Darnton comes across as a fan of censorship (he emphatically doesn’t), but it does create a more nuanced picture of what they do most of the time.

Of course, what they were doing all the time was still censoring writers (Darnton focuses almost exclusively on books, with some theater stuff thrown in), even if most of the time their motives were more benign than we might expect. The French censors Darnton talks about who squelched a bawdy insider narrative of life at Versailles might have thought it was low brow trash, but they were also aware that it made fun of the royal court and you can’t have that. That dynamic is even more clear with the British, who developed a real knack for decoding incipient strains of Indian nationalism and independence movements in modern retellings of ancient myths (not for nothing, but if you see rebellion in every work you read, maybe that’s saying something about you?). The East Germans, of course, made no bones that they were making sure new books were ideologically appropriate, regardless of the genre.

One interesting dynamic that plays out across all three eras is that every regime at least pays lip service to the importance of free speech. That is, none of the regimes saw their restriction of particular kinds of speech as any kind of violation. Hell, the East German censors (Darnton interviews two) don’t even think they engaged in censorship! This is true wherever you are, including the United States. The “freedom of speech” guaranteed by the First Amendment is  term of legal art that excludes things like libel and obscenity. The grey areas of those definitions are where the rubber meets the road.

Given that these censors didn’t see their work as being conflict with a commitment to free speech, it’s not surprising that they tended to find objectionable material wherever they looked for it. If Hitchens was right that religion poisons everything then censorship does, too. There is no book or literary work so minor that it can’t be subversive or just not up to quality if you look at it from the right angle.

Which is perhaps the most important takeaway from Darnton’s work. Any censorship scheme is going to be carried out by human beings (or AI programmed by human beings, I suppose). Those human beings will come from different backgrounds, with different philosophies, shaped by whatever flavor of regime is in charge at the time. If you think there’s some kind of speech that should be obviously off limits – say, “hate speech” – it’s worth considering who’s going to decide what that is and what it isn’t. Chances are, they aren’t going to get it “right” all the time (but they’ll think they are).

Which is why I might come back to the idea of using a censor as a character in a story sometime. There’s more going on there than I suspected, even if it’s perhaps not as complicated as the person doing the censoring might want it to be.

The Many Mutinies on the Bounty

Sometimes I fall down rabbit holes. This particular one I’m going to blame on Turner Classic Movies.

As I think I’ve said before, part of my work morning routine is to flip through the schedule on TCM to see if there’s anything worth recording that day. Months ago I found such a thing, the 1935 version of Mutiny on the Bounty, starring Charles Laughton and Clark Gable.

Having never seen it, or any other Bounty story, I recorded it. It sat on the TiVo long enough that TCM also showed the 1962 version (with Marlon Brando), so I recorded that as well.

When my wife saw both sitting there, she wondered aloud about if I intended to watch the 1984 version, Bounty, with Mel Gibson and Anthony Hopkins (and Daniel Day Lewis and Liam Neeson!).

So, one Saturday, we did the deep dive and watched all three back-to-back-to-back. And then I read Caroline Alexander’s The Bounty: The True Story of the Mutiny on the Bounty to actually get the history of the whole thing.

Watching different versions of the same story, the history of which is not as clear as you might think, made for some interesting comparisons.

But first, the basic history – in 1787 Bounty left England, under the command of William Bligh, for a journey to Tahiti. There, the crew would harvest breadfruit plants for transport to Jamaica, where it was hoped they could be replanted and used as a cheap food for the enslaved population. Sometime after Bounty left Tahiti one of Bligh’s underlings, Fletcher Christian, led a mutiny. Bligh and several loyal men were put adrift in a launch (and managed to make it back to civilization), while Christian and the others found their way to Pitcairn Island, where their descendants live to this day.

What’s particularly interesting about the history (from Alexander’s book, at least) is that there is a gaping hole in the record when it comes to Christian. Bligh, the men in the launch, and even some of the other mutineers returned to England where there were various inquiries into the mutiny, but Christian never did, dying (or being murdered) on Pitcairn. His precise motivation for the mutiny is unknown, therefore, and leaves a lot of room for fictional variation in the story.

For example, the portrayals of Bligh vary considerably between the three movies. As played by Laughton  in 1935, Bligh is a tough-love legal enforcer. The law of the sea is harsh and brutal, but it’s necessary to keep discipline on what is a very dangerous voyage. The 1962 Bligh, by contrast (played by Trevor Howard), appears to get off on the punishment he dishes out (which Christian calls him out for). He may use the legalish language that Laughton did, but it appears to be a cover for more personal motives. Hopkins in Bounty, on the other hand, dishes out much less discipline (particularly before the reach Tahiti), but seems much more paranoid about possible plots. Per Alexander’s book, Bounty was probably the closest to correct, as Bligh didn’t appear to be any firmer of a disciplinarian than the normal English captain of the time. That said, Bligh also suffered a rebellion (land mutiny?) when he was a territorial governor in Australia later in life, so clearly there was something about his leadership style that rubbed some people the wrong way.

The same is true for Christian, whose motives shift from telling to telling. Gable’s version, perhaps polished to match his matinee idol status, was driven to mutiny on behalf of the lowly sailors who Bligh abused. Notably, that version of Christian had served with Bligh before and had some idea that there might be trouble. It’s a pretty simple narrative. The 1962 version Brando played takes longer to get to the same place and, when he does so, simply snaps, rather than more coolly plots the mutiny. This Christian didn’t know Bligh before, so he’s perhaps more shocked by the brutality. Where Brando’s Christian really differs from Gable’s is the weight that command puts on him after the mutiny. Gibson’s version is motivated less by Bligh’s cruelty (since there’s less of it) than his affection for life on Tahiti. He appears, to quote Londo Molari, to have “gone native” and is willing to do whatever it takes to get back. This Christian didn’t just know Bligh prior to being on Bounty but was good friends with him, which again kind of pushes the cruelty angle to the side. Which of these is closest to truth, if any, is anybody’s guess.

The movies differ considerably in what happens after the mutiny, too. In the 1935 version, after Bligh makes it back to England, he is exonerated of anything to do with the mutiny, then heads off back to the South Pacific (true!) where he tracks down Christian on Tahiti and forces him to book it to Pitcairn (false!). Post-mutiny life for Christian is pretty swell, as least until Bligh shows up. In the 1962 version, Bligh is again acquitted, but with some comments from the judges afterwards that maybe he had it coming, anyway. There’s no return voyage. For Christian, as I said, command weighs heavily on him so much so that on Pitcairn he floats the idea of returning to England to tell their story. This prompts others to burn Bounty in the bay and Christian dies trying to save it (ending courtesy of Billy Wilder, rather than any historical basis). The 1984 version gives Bligh a full exoneration, while making Christian’s life after the mutiny even more miserable. The landing on Pitcairn comes off less of a triumph and more pathetic than anything else.

What none of the movies really do is dig into what happened in England once Bligh returned. There really was a court martial at which many of the mutineers (returned from Tahiti by other vessels) were convicted of mutiny, although many were acquitted (including a potential ancestor of mine!). Several were sentenced to hang, but two were pardoned. News coverage of the court martial was largely favorable to Bligh, but Alexander chronicles how that shifted over the years, thanks in part to Christian’s family and some of the other sailors involved. It’s safe to say that the popular conception of Bligh, closer to Laughton’s and Howard’s portrayals than to Hopkins’, is largely due to their out-of-court efforts.

Particularly interesting in the variations is that the 1935 and 1952 movies are both based on the same set of novels, so you’d think they’d be more similar. They’re both big screen spectacles and the 1952 version was no doubt made just to take advantage of color, but they are quite different in the people whose stories they are telling. I think I prefer the 1935 one. Laughton’s Bligh may be the farthest from the truth, but he’s pretty compelling and in his devotion to rules without empathy scarier to me than Howard’s psycho Bligh (remember, I’m a public defender by day). While I appreciate the ambiguity of the 1984 film, it doesn’t resonate quite as much (in spite of the Vangelis score).

Usually when a movie is made about a historical event the discourse breaks down into whether the movie got it “right” or how “wrong” it actually got things. The whole Bounty situation is a good example of how history isn’t so obvious in lots of situations and lends itself to different interpretations. Surely there’s another Bounty movie or TV series in the works that’ll provide an entirely different perspective, too.

Weekly Read – An Assassin In Utopia

I’ve said before that book titles can be tricky, particularly for non-fiction, since they act as a kind of “promise, a declaration of what kind of book the reader is getting into). That said, Susan Wels’ An Assassin In Utopia: The True Story of a Nineteenth-Century Sex Cult and a President’s Murder makes a hell of a promise. Pity it doesn’t come close to fulfilling it.

The sex cult in question is the Oneida Community, initially founded in New York in 1848 and persisting, in various forms, for the next three decades. The dead president in question is James Garfield, who perished after being shot only six months after taking office in 1881. What purportedly brings these two things together is Garfield’s assassin, Charles Guiteau, who had a couple of brief stints as a member of the Oneida Community.

It’s a pretty slender thread to tie together a book and, to be fair, Wels doesn’t really try too hard. As I said, Guiteau spent some time at Oneida, but given his particular mental quirks and psychopathy you can’t say what he learned there caused him to shoot Garfield (he couldn’t even get laid in a commune devoted to an early version of “free love”!). Rather, she collects stray historical anecdotes that cover several decades while Oneida was in operation and Garfield found his way to the White House. Many of them are interesting in their own right, but they don’t feel cohesive.

Which is a shame, because I would have loved more detail on the Oneida Community itself. Born from forward-thinking social ideas, and eventually infused with ideals of political socialism, Oneida was one of the first of many utopian communities that popped up in the United States in that period. That is descended into a typical sex cult, where a few leaders (old men all) decided who slept with who and, of course, who slept with them. Minors are raped, too, in the name of whatever ideals the leaders dreamed up, a pattern that echoes down through the succeeding generations.

Indeed, Oneida disappears entirely from the narrative once the focus turns to Garfield’s election (and surprise nomination in the first place) and assassination. Wels covers that briskly, but the shooting, and Garfield’s lingering as doctors probed his wounds until he died, is covered more thoroughly (and interestingly) in Candice Millard’s The Destiny of the Republic: A Tale Madness, Medicine and the Murder of a President. As I said way back when:

While Millard spends a great amount of time (particularly in the book’s second half) on Garfield’s lingering death, the first half of the book is spent setting up not only the lives of Garfield and Guiteau up to that point, but the world in which they lived. It’s a fascinating snapshot, showing both how different the United States of the 1870s-1880s is compared to today, and how disappointingly similar the two eras are.

***

In the end, where the book really shines is in the contrast of Garfield and Guiteau, two men swept into their fatal confrontation by things beyond their control. It’s ironic that Garfield, who never really wanted to be president, is the kind of person who we should want to become president – educated and inquisitive, a voracious reader, and apparently a genuinely decent guy. And yet, even as part of a very select club of assassinated presidents, he’s pretty much forgotten these days. Of course, Guiteau is not exactly a household name, either.

If you’ve never dived into this period of American history, or the Garfield assassination, this book is a reasonable start. Beyond that, The Destiny of the Republic does better on the assassination itself and there’s probably a more thorough treatment of the Oneida Community out there, too (which I might have to seek out).

Sing us out, Charlie . . .

Weekly Watches & Reads – UK History Edition

In May, my wife and I took a much delayed (thanks COVID!) vacation to the United Kingdom, hitting London, the Scottish Highlands and Isle of Skye, and Edinburgh over the course of a couple of weeks.

As is my wont, the trip inspired me to come home and read/listen/watch various things about that part of the world. Here are some quick thoughts.

The whole of the UK is steeped in history and it occurred while I was there that I knew precious little of it, particularly when it came to Scotland. I remedied that by digesting the entirety of Scotland: A History from Earliest Times, by Alistair Moffat.

Never was a book so aptly named, given that it spends a good hunk of its epic runtime (23+ hours in audiobook format) covering the geological history of Scotland before human beings even enter into it. Honestly, I wish the book would have condensed that considerably, since Moffat then covers basically all of Scottish human history (my other criticism is that he goes too close to current, lapsing from history to journalism in the end). As a result, it has a kind of bird’s eye view of things, without a whole lot of detail, but for someone like me who didn’t have a great idea of Scottish history, it was just about perfect. Particularly interesting to me was how Sir Walter Scott (who has a huge memorial in Edinburgh, pictured above) essentially created the modern conception of being “Scottish,” drawing on Highland things that had mostly been suppressed previously.

One of this historical things about which I knew nothing at all before we hit Scotland were the Jacobite Risings that happened there in the 17th & 18th Centuries. The last, started in 1745, was particularly prominent, in spite of the fact that it ended in bloody defeat for the rebels at the Battle of Culloden. We visited the battlefield and I wanted to get a better sense of the battle, so I read/listened to a book with the title Culloden, by Trevor Royle, which you’d think would do the trick.

Except that the full title is Culloden: Scotland’s Last Battle and the Forging of the British Empire. The Culloden part is, maybe, one third of the book, although perhaps it doesn’t need much more than that (it took place on wide open terrain and was over in about an hour – Gettysburg it was not). The rest is about how many of the officers and men at Culloden went on to fight Britain’s imperial wars around the world, with a decent focus on North America. It was interesting, in its own way, but not quite what I was looking for.

My thought was Culloden would be a good subject for a movie, so I was surprised that there weren’t many out there dealing with it directly (as opposed to using it as some kind of background). I finally found one called Chasing the Deer that I was able to watch on YouTube.

I was drawn to this partly because one of the actors is Fish, original lead singer of Marillion and successful solo artist in his own right. I knew he’d done a little bit of acting (this was his only feature film) so that made certain I had to check it out. It was well done in terms of tone and accuracy, but the small budget came through and the script wasn’t great (neither, sad to say, was Fish, although he was about par for the course with the rest of the cast). It did give you some idea of what the actual battle was like, however, so that counts for something.

My final bit of reading when I got home was Devil-Land: England Under Siege 1588-1688, by Clare Jackson.

We were in Westminster Abbey and I saw Oliver Cromwell’s tomb (well, slab of tile under which he’s buried) and realized I’d never really dug into Cromwell or the English Civil Wars. This book looked like just the thing to fill that gap. It’s just as long as Scotland, but only focused on about 100 years, after all. Still, I was disappointed that this was also pretty high-level history, without a lot of detail about life on the ground. In addition, the Civil Wars didn’t get any singular treatment and were just events along the way that happened to involve the royals that were really the focus of the book. There was no discussion of any political philosophy underlying the Republicans or Royalists. What is clear to me, however, is that this period was hugely influential on the American Founding Fathers, as you can pick precise parts of the Constitution that seem designed to prevent atrocities and injustices that happened during this era.

Speaking of Westminster Abbey, part of what we took in there were the tombs of Elizabeth I and Mary Queen of Scots. Somewhere along the way I found out there was a fairly recent movie about the pair, cleverly titled Mary Queen of Scots, with Saoirse Ronan in the title role and Margot Robbie as Elizabeth.

As the title suggests this is a Mary-forward portrayal of events and does give you a sense of the era (the claims of historical inaccuracy, based on my reading, are mostly down to interpretation rather than outright incorrectness). That said, it’s fairly dull for the most part, skipping large periods of time in order to cover all of Mary’s time in Scotland, but precious little of her time as a prisoner in England. And as much as I love David Tennant, one of John Knox’s rants on how wicked women are was enough. Nice bit of synergy, though – I started Devil-Land just after we saw this and it starts with the execution of Mary, so it was a nice transition.

Much less period, and not at all historical, but definitely getting points for Highland isolation is Calibre, from 2018.

Calibre is the story of two buddies, one of whom is getting ready to become a father, who jaunt into the Scottish wilderness for a hunting trip. They wind up in a very small town filled with very creepy people who are full of unheeded warnings. A tragic accident happens and the guys get stuck in town without an easy way out. The movies deals in tropes, to be sure (the “small town creepy hick” cliche transcends oceans), but the atmosphere is really well maintained and the acting is quite good. Like I said, nothing historical, but does give you a sense of what it’s like in the middle of nowhere Scotland (see also “Loch Henry,” one of the episodes of the new season of Black Mirror).

Spending a few days in a foreign land is hardly enough time to get a sense of the place. What it can do, at least for me, is spark a deeper interest in the area’s history and culture, such that it will always be something that captures my interest. I figure British history is a rabbit hole I’m going to plumet down into for a good long while to come.

A Bit of Justice for Cousin Charlie

I am not, in general, a big reader of historical fiction. Not anything against it, I think I’d just rather read the history itself. Nonetheless, when Hilary Mantel died last year I thought I probably ought to check out some of her work. A little leery of wading directly into the Thomas Cromwell books I scanned her bibliography and saw a book called The Giant O’Brien. It rang a small bell and, after a bit of poking around, I found it was about, perhaps, a distant relative.

Said giant was Charles Byrne, who measured over seven-and-a-half feet tall. As chronicled in Mantel’s book, he leaves rural Ireland to go to London and become an attraction. What’s really interesting about the man in the book (whether it tracks reality I don’t know) is that he was very much in control of his exploitation. He’s not a simpleton dragged away from home by someone out to make a quick buck. Rather, he’s well aware of what’s going on and happy to make his way in the world in that manner, with the possibility of a young death hovering over him the whole time.

In the book, Byrne is pursued by a surgeon, John Hunter, who is a collector of “specimens” and wants the giant’s skeleton once he’s dead. Byrne makes it perfectly clear that he doesn’t want this to happen, but is betrayed by the hangars-on that have come with him to London, who eventually make the deal with Hunter for a few hundred pounds. The result was that Byrne’s skeleton was put on display at Hunter’s museum, where it became the most famous part of its collection.

There is some dispute as to how, precisely, Byrne’s bones came into Hunter’s possession – let’s hope he wasn’t so cruelly betrayed – but there’s no doubt Byrne didn’t want to go on display like a museum piece. Nonetheless, he was and there he hung for the next two centuries.

Until just recently. The museum is nearing reopening after several years of renovation and have announced that Byrne’s skeleton will no longer be on public display:

“What happened historically and what Hunter did was wrong,” said Dawn Kemp, a director at the Royal College of Surgeons of England, of which the Hunterian Museum is now part. “How do you redress some of these historical wrongs? The first step is to take Byrne’s skeleton off display.”

The real question now is what else, if anything, should be done with it. On the one hand, if we’re rectifying historical wrongs and Byrne wished not to be a specimen that should be the end of the discussion. On the other, there is something to be said for having Byrne’s bones around for scientific study:

“We shouldn’t think that we now know everything,” said Marta Korbonits, a professor of endocrinology at Queen Mary University in London, who has researched Byrne’s genes.

The research “isn’t done and dusted,” she added.

Indeed, Byrne’s skeleton has offered up new answers as medicine has evolved. In 1909, an American surgeon studied Byrne’s remains, and discovered that he had a tumor in his brain. Then, about a century later, researchers including Dr. Korbonits extracted DNA from Byrne’s teeth and found that he also had a rare genetic mutation that had been unknown until 2006.

“Without the public view, we wouldn’t have made that link,” Dr. Korbonits said.

I’ll admit, I’m a little conflicted. On the one hand, since I believe that a body after death is just meat and bone and the person who it once was is gone, I don’t get too worked up over what people do with dead bodies, particularly at the remove of a couple of centuries. And if there is some broader benefit for mankind that’s a good thing, right? On the other, disrespecting a person’s wishes is a shitty thing to do and it seems if you’re going to right that wrong you have to go all the way.

In the end, there’s no good answer, given the proven good that having Byrne’s skeleton around has done, although I could see a compromise – since we’ve gotten more out of him than we ever should have, maybe it’s time to say “thanks” and let the guy rest? It’s the least we can do for cousin Charlie.

Weekly Watch: The Most Dangerous Animal of All

One of my favorite David Fincher movies (of which there are several) is Zodiac. What makes it work so well isn’t that it “solves” one of the most infamous cold cases in American history, but that it compellingly portrays how the obsession with trying to solve something that might not be solvable can ruin a person’s life. In the end, it becomes less a triumph of perseverance and grit than a pathetic throwing away of a life’s potential.

The four-episode documentary series The Most Dangerous Animal of All, adapted from a book of the same name, is an interesting companion piece to Zodiac, although I’d hesitate to call it perfect.

It’s about Gary Stewart, who was adopted as an infant into a loving family. For decades, he struggled with questions of his real identity and what it meant to be abandoned by his birth parents, so he started working to track them down. He found his birth mother easily enough and through her learned that his father was a guy named Earl Van Best, Jr.

Best was a bad dude at the time he met Stewart’s mother. And by “met” I really mean kidnapped, raped, and abused. He was 27 years old at the time, she was only 14. Their “love affair” even made headlines, allowing Stewart to get not just a feel for the circumstances of his birth but pictures and even some in-court film of his father when he was eventually caught, convicted, and sentenced for his crimes.

All that was bad enough, but then Stewart, armed with a mugshot of his father, saw a documentary on the Zodiac killer and that iconic drawing of the suspect:

Stewart realized it looked a lot like his father. This sets him off on an odyssey to determine whether his father was, in fact, Zodiac and solve this coldest of cold cases. Through the first three of the four episodes, Stewart marshals his evidence and it sounds pretty compelling. He wrote the book upon which the series was based and then, well, it all went to shit.

What’s particularly interesting is, according to this article, said going to shit started happening while this documentary was in production. This left the creators in a pickle – how to deal with the evidence that seemed to show that Stewart’s argument that Best was Zodiac was full of shit? The way they handled it was to present, point by point, experts debunking each of Stewart’s claims – to him. Essentially, they made the documentary on one track, all the while building the case against Best as the Zodiac (culminating in records showing he wasn’t even in the United States when the Zodiac killings took place) on another, only bringing them together in the end.

The result is compellingly awkward. You might expect that Stewart, confronted with the evidence contradicting his theory (some of which implies he just made shit up), that Stewart would come clean or break down in some way, blame the stress of his quest for driving him down this particular rabbit hole. Instead, he steadfastly holds onto his conclusion that his birth father – who had nothing to do with raising him – is the Zodiac killer.

To what end? It’s not clear. Maybe it’s because Stewart is so desperate for a personal history, an identity that latching onto one that horrible is preferable to not having one at all. Maybe it’s that, if he’s going to be the offspring of a monster, anyway (which Best, by all evidence, was), might as well be the offspring of one of the most infamous (and unidentified) monsters of all time? Or, maybe it was all a grift, with Stewart coming up with a slick way to monetize his search into his background.

I don’t think it’s the last one. From the documentary it really appears that Stewart believes the story he’s trying to sell. Either of the others are heart wrenching, in their own way, and make you feel sorry for him. Which is what makes this series so compelling – come for the potential true crime bombshell, stay for the fascinating portrait of a man who is so wrapped up in the distant past that he can’t come to grips with the more recent version.