Sketches of Spain, Part 3 – Granada & Madrid

Last month my wife, Kelly, and I embarked on the “Two Weeks in Spain” so famed in song.  It was a wonderful trip and impossible to convey all we were able to do and see, but over the next few posts I wanted to share a little bit of what made the journey so special. Each post has musical accompaniment, so press “play” at the bottom and enjoy.

Granada

At one point I said that Cordoba reminded me of New Orleans – old city surrounded by modern  big city – with the topography of Morgantown – lots of hills. If that’s accurate then Granada could be described similarly, but with the topography of Logan – an old town built in a valley with steep hills on either side.

On one hill is the Alhambra, perhaps the go-to example of “Moorish buildings in Spain” in the minds of most people. More of that later, but after we arrived in town (via another drive through the countryside) and had some lunch, we decided to trek up the other hill, into a neighborhood called the Albaicín, which is where the original city was founded.

And those weren’t the steepest ones!

It was a haul, but the view was great.

View from a wall, looking over at the Alhambra.
High altitude selfie.

The Albaicín was where, during the early days of the Spanish Civil War, the Republicans made their resistance, using the narrow streets and hills as natural fortifications. Alas, the Fascists just moved artily into the Alhambra and shelled them into surrender.

Our main goal for that evening, though, was something I’d been trying to set up since before COVID hit – seeing a soccer game in Europe. We tried to go see Leeds play during our UK trip a few years back, but couldn’t get tickets (and a one-day rail strike changed our plans, anyway). When we knew where we were going in Spain I dove into finding a place to watch a game. In the end, the only place where that could work out was in Granada.

Granada CF, which dates back to 1931, currently plays in the Spanish second division, but were in La Liga as recently as 2023-2024. Their colors are red, white, and blue, which seemed appropriate, even if the resulting kit feels very FC Dallas at times.

Good seats!

“Granada,” as well as being the name of the city, is also Spanish for “pomegranate” (although the word origins are different), which explains the club’s sentient pomegranate mascot, Granain:

You, too, will have nightmares.

The stadium was about the size of a modern MLS stadium and was probably two-thirds full. The local supporters group, behind one goal, were pretty vocal and the rest of the crowd got into it fairly often. We really hated the right back from Real Valladolid for some reason, but we joined in booing him every time he touched the ball.

First half action.

The ball came into our area of the stands twice. Once a guy sitting behind Kelly fumbled it into the seat next to her, spilling our popcorn. A fan down the row tossed us his to make up for it (I noted later that he had a backpack full of snacks – apparently they don’t care so much about bringing your own stuff into a game). The second time a guy sitting in front of me calmly stood up and headed the ball back onto the pitch. Best header of the night!

Ultimately, the good guys won 2-1 – so I now have a team in Spain to root for!

For while, though, I thought we’d never make it back to the hotel. A map on the city website said there was a taxi stand right at the corner of the block where the stadium was. Alas, there was none. Two helpful fans leaving the game explained that they block off the streets before the game lets out so the cabs stay away. They pointed us to a spot a couple of blocks down to try. That didn’t really work and we couldn’t get the local cab app to work, either. We relocated again, about another block away, and finally got lucky. For a while there I thought we were walking home (45 minutes, per Google) in the dark in a foreign city. Whew!

The next morning, it was on to the Alhambra.

Sort of. There’s a lot to the place, so we actually started with the Generalife, a more modern palace and grounds with, as damned near everywhere in Granada, brilliant views.

Garden in the Generalife.
That view.

It’s nice, but hardly the main attraction.

That said, the Alhambra is not a building, so much as it is a collection of them. It was once, essentially, its own city. So in addition to defensive walls and such it’s got a cathedral, a former convent, and an unfinished palace that (hundreds of years later) became a museum.

So, naturally you had to have water for the place – so a Roman-era aqueduct did the trick (bringing water from the source of the river up in the mountains).

What have the Romans ever done for us?
Walkway flanked by shrubberies on either side.
The former convent, now a hotel.
Another view of the former convent.

There are still a few people who actually live in the Alhambra and many who work there, with a street of shops open on the walk down to the main attraction.

Kelly headed downhill.

Primarily, of course, the Alhambra was a fortress.

Towers and turrets.
Barracks, excavated down to the foundation.
Entrance to the dungeon (there ain’t no steps in there, neither).

You don’t build on the high ground for nothing.

The more modern part of the city, with the cathedral.
The Albaicín. I think the bare spot there just right of center is where we hiked to the day before.

But it was also a very elaborate palace.

Vaulted, carved ceiling.
Every room with a view!
Our guide explained that, by some 20th-century proof, there’s a certain (pretty big) number of variants on this kind of design – this place has all of them.
A not great picture of a really beautiful courtyard.
Better picture, lesser courtyard.
Ceiling painting.
Ceiling with a very stalactite-like finish.

The most famous part of the place is the Court of the Lions, which includes this spectacular fountain.

The fountain through columns.
From the other side.

In true Tufnel fashion, nobody really knows why they were built or what they’re supposed to represent. Each one is unique, though, which shows the amount of time it took to build them all (in the 14th century).

The place isn’t just ancient. Charles V, Holy Roman Emperor and King of Spain, started building a palace here in 1527, but it went unfinished and was abandoned in 1637 (well after his death). It was finally “completed” in 1927, but only got a roof in 1967. There’s a metaphor in there somewhere. Nice courtyard, though.

Lots of square footage, but how much is usable?

We spent the afternoon exploring the city.

A waterfall on the way down the hill from the Alhambra.
Washington Irving, who wrote “Tales from the Alhambra” after coming to Granada on diplomatic duty.
For my guitar playing friends and relations.

We stopped at the Casa de Zafra, a restored home that serves as a museum of the Albaicín.

Courtyard.
Yet again, an amazing view (of . . . c’mon, guess!).

Stumbled into some street flamenco.

Have dance, will travel.

And a little torture, at the Museo de Olvidados (the “museum of the forgotten”), filled with toys from the Inquisition.

Doesn’t get much worse than a metal pig mask.
The street outside our hotel at dusk. It’s narrower than it looks!

Madrid

We really only went back to Madrid because it was the best place to fly home from. Nonetheless, it was a good excuse for another good dinner at a local place and one last batch of churros!

One (or two . . . or ten) for the road.

A word about . . . language.

I will admit – I was a little skeptical we’d be able to wade through this trip given that neither of us actually speak Spanish. When we went to Cambodia we had guides/translators with us the whole time and when we went to the UK, well they speak English (basically). Thankfully, most of the folks we dealt with had enough English proficiency that we could communicate well enough. It was a little more stressful in, say, train stations, were most announcement were in Spanish only, but day-to-day, we got along pretty well. A large part of that is down to the kindness of the Spanish people we dealt with (aside from the graffiti artists in Madrid).

Take it away . . . Joaquín (and friends)

After a few riffs on the original, here it is in all its glory, Joaquín Rodrigo’s Concecierto de Aranjuez.

And because I can’t resist finishing up with the prog, Emerson, Lake, & Palmer send us off with “Canario,” an adaptation of another Rodrigo piece (which is excellent – ignore the horrific fashion choices).

Sketches of Spain, Part 2 – Seville & Malaga

Last month my wife, Kelly, and I embarked on the “Two Weeks in Spain” so famed in song.  It was a wonderful trip and impossible to convey all we were able to do and see, but over the next few posts I wanted to share a little bit of what made the journey so special. Each post has musical accompaniment, so press “play” at the bottom and enjoy.

Seville

A short train ride and we were in Seville (no barbers in sight!).

Our hotel in Malaga was . . . odd. For one thing, it wasn’t a single building, but a bunch of old homes all tied together into a hotel. As a result we had to take a tunnel (and about three elevators) to get to our room.

Kelly, hoping this doesn’t turn into some kind if “Shining” situation.

And, well, this was awkward.

Excuse me . . .

Our hotel (of which more later) was deep in the old town and, as in Cordoba, we set off to explore a bit before dinner.

When we left the hotel there was a crowd starting to gather and what looked like a community band milling around in the street. By the time we got back the crowd was so thick we couldn’t actually reach our hotel. Turns out it was just a few doors down from Iglesia de Santa Maria la Blanca and it was about time for a processional.

Numerous Catholic guys waiting on the thing to get rolling.

It took a while for the whole coterie to make its way out of the church, but the ending was worth it.

A very elaborate float (?) with Mary and lots of candles.

I later asked someone at the hotel how often that kind of thing happened (it was Sunday, after all) and apparently it’s not super common, but not really rare, either. While we were there we saw some posters for other similar events for different saints.

The next day we dove into the history of Seville with a tour that included both the local palace, the Real Alcazar (still used, occasionally, by the Spanish royal family) and the cathedral. The Alcazar has a lot of fascinating history – it was through here that most of the wealth of the Spanish empire in the Americas came into the country (and was taxed). It’s also got some interesting architecture, blending styles from various cultures.

Main courtyard, with a different-era palace on each of three sides.
Big glass skylight on the first palace, built by a Christian king with lots of Muslim influences.
A reception hall in the main palace.

My favorite detail were these balconies, installed by Pietro I, which are, in fact, fake:

The ceiling is designed to represent the cosmos – with mirrors at the center to reflect the king at the center.

The idea was to impress visitors with the possibility of rooms on a higher level. Potemkin balconies – who’d have thunk it?

An interior courtyard, meant to depict the Muslim idea of paradise (a gift from the calif, with whom the king was good friends).

Another lovely detail – this is a confessional chapel built right outside the big room next door where the king held lavish parties. I correctly guessed was that the idea was to go inside, sin your brains out, then come out here to repent.

Sin. Repent. Repeat.
A tapestry in the very swanky party room.

As a good palace does, there were gardens, too.

Kelly in the garden.
A peacock (peahen? peabeing?) being photogenic in the gardens.

The cathedral, well, it was amazing. Completed in 1519 it’s the largest Gothic cathedral in the world and the third largest of any kind on the planet.

Outside the cathedral.
Vaults upon vaults (with stained glass).
Stained glass and paintings.
Another choir loft (I think).

Indeed, the altar is the largest in the world – the Vatican has a scale copy (quite the flex).

So large it’s hard to get a good picture!

Among the many people interred in the cathedral are a pair of Columbuses (Columbi?), Christopher and his second son, Ferdinand. Christopher, as you might expect, has a pretty elaborate tomb:

The remains of Christopher Columbus (probably) – at least 80% of him.

Whether that’s actually him in there has subject to some debate (his remains moved around a lot after his death), but appears to be settled now thanks to DNA comparisons with his son. Ferdinand, on the other hand, gets a respectful tile over his grave in the floor.

Columbus’ son, a man rich in books (and other things).

Ferdinand lacked the accomplishments of his father, but he was rich and, in particular, had an extensive library. He guaranteed his resting place in the cathedral by agreeing to give the church his collection upon his death. It’s still available to researchers.

Part of the cathedral is the Giralda, a tower that was once the minaret for the mosque on the site and is now the bell tower for the cathedral. We climbed up all 37 ramps (instead of stairs, allegedly so the muezzin back in the day could ride a burro to the top to do the call to prayer), which provided some great views of the city.

The Giralda at night.

Still a long way up, though!

That night we had a cool experience, a combination tapas walking tour and flamenco experience. Our guide – a very outgoing French expat named Remy – led us from bar to bar for some food and wine, all the while explaining the history and basics of flamenco. Then, a flamenco show:

The two dancers.

I didn’t realize going in how improvisational these were. I assumed there was some choreography, moves that went with certain songs, what have you. As explained by Remy, and as evident from the performance, it’s very free flowing and in the moment. I particularly enjoyed when one dancer just kind of kept going past where the guitarist and vocalists thought was the end and they wound up pushing to a very joyful end. The guitar player was a fucking beast, by the way.

The entire ensemble (including two vocalists).

The next day (we spent three nights in Seville) was very low key, with a bath and spa time in the morning and a cruise on the “river” (actually a canal that follows the original course of the river) as a means to see some more of the city.

Another in my long-running series of “pictures of Kelly taking pictures of things,” in this case a fountain whose name I can’t recollect.

The spa/bath experience was interesting. Massages don’t do much for me (Kelly loves them) and I wind up feeling awkward and tense rather than relaxed. The baths, however, were nice. One set was divided into hot/warm/cold zones, while another was, essentially a giant jacuzzi. I split my time between those two, for the most part. We were supposed to have an additional bath experience in their rooftop pool, but it was down for maintenance (I think it would have been too cold, but whatever). As compensation, we were given a wine bath – a huge tub filled with wine. In which we sat. And drank wine (and nibbled on cheese and crackers). If ever there is a “this is what it feels just before the peasants revolt” setting, that was it.

Malaga

Rather than take the train, we hired a car to make it to Malaga (the train schedules just didn’t work out, for whatever reason). It was a nice change of pace, literally, and gave us a chance to take in some of the landscape. This part of Spain is pretty dry and not particularly lush. It is covered all over with olive trees, however (Spain, apparently, is the largest producer of olive oil in the world – and it’s quite tasty!). Nearer to the coast it got mountainous, which made me think a bit of home, which was nice.

Malaga had a unique feature in terms of its old town, a fairly intact Roman-era theater.

Roman theater, with the Alcazaba on the hill in the background.

You can sit in the stone bleachers and imagine someone taking in the latest work by Seneca or Gaius Maecenas Melissus and complaining, “I’ve seen it before.”

Could definitely fling produce at the stage from this distance.

Up the hill is the Alcazaba, a fortress dating back to the 11th Century. It’s laid on hill so it really clings to the landscape (like Obert’s house in Gods of the Empire, if you’re familiar).

Kelly beside the outer wall.
Towers in various states of decay.
Garden with fountain.

It does provide some great views of the city, particularly the harbor.

A view from a hill (as the song goes) – I think the big circular thing is a bullring.
Kelly, with the harbor in the background.

We decided not to hike all the way to the top of the hill, to the Gibralfaro castle. Gotta know your limits.

The main reason we went to Malaga was Picasso. He was born there and there’s a museum dedicated to him there.

Music while we waited to get in.

It’s pretty well done, covering the breadth of his artistic output.

“Bather”
“Flute Player”

I liked his take on art: “We all know that art is not truth. Art is a lie that makes us realize the truth.”

Kelly’s favorite – “Man Looking at a Sleeping Woman”
My favorite – “Reclining Nude and Cat”

That said, a lot of his more well-known stuff is elsewhere (such as the Reina Sofia in Madrid). And the museum steered clear of Picasso’s personal life. A little post-visit digging shows why, as he was pretty much a monster to those around him.

The other reason we went to Malaga was to get a little sense of the Mediterranean coast. We didn’t really “go to the beach,” but we did walk down and breathe in some salt air (Kelly waded in a bit – the water was cold). It’s very pretty.

Kelly wades.

We wound up on this spit that juts out into the bay.

Big damned fishing poles.
Selfie in the sun.

With that, we were off to Granada . . .

A word about . . . transport.

I’ve mentioned taking trains or cars to get around while we were in Spain, but I wanted to say a couple of things about transport in general. For one, the high-speed trains are amazing. The one we took from Madrid to Cordoba almost hit 300 kph, which is more than 180 mph. That’s absolutely hauling ass. Of course, when things go wrong at that speed they really go wrong, as evidenced by the horrific crash on that line a few days after we got back. And, it has to be said, none of our trains left on time. Cabs were useful in the cities, even if sometimes it was hard to find one (as you’ll see in Granada).

Take it away . . . Chick

Another jazz exploration of some of the themes from Joaquín Rodrigo’s Concecierto de Aranjuez. Originally recorded by Return to Forever, I thought this live version from years later with Chick’s band hit the spot.

Sketches of Spain, Part 1 – Madrid & Cordoba

Last month my wife, Kelly, and I embarked on the “Two Weeks in Spain” so famed in song.  It was a wonderful trip and impossible to convey all we were able to do and see, but over the next few posts I wanted to share a little bit of what made the journey so special. Each post has musical accompaniment, so press “play” at the bottom and enjoy.

Departure

Naturally, I had to check in with Señor Foot on the way out of town, at our local “international” airport.

Checking in with our local cryptid on the way out.

The flights were, thankfully, uneventful and resulted in only a minor amount of panic from me (I’m not a good flyer).

Madrid

Our first stop was Madrid, where we would stay for a couple of nights before heading off into Andalusia, where we spent the bulk of our days. We landed around noon local time, which felt much later due to jet lag. Instead of falling into bed, we decided to push on through dinnertime and try to adapt to the time change.

Our hotel was right downtown, near a busy traffic circle and a park frequently used for protests. There was a McDonald’s on the corner (although Burger King seemed more prevalent overall), but we bypassed a taste of home and headed for the Plaza Mayor.

Plaza del Mayor. The guy on the horse is Felipe III.

The plaza is ringed by restaurants and tourist trap shops, but Kelly had a different destination in mind. We walked through the square, down a set of stairs and an alley, and had our first experience with Spanish cuisine – churros con chocolate!

Yes, they’re even better than they look.

The place, San Gines, struck me as the Spanish version of Cafe du Monde in New Orleans – they basically do one thing, but they do it very well. That thing is fresh, crispy churros (no cinnamon, like we get here), served with a cup of drinking chocolate (think hot chocolate that aspires to be mousse). The chocolate clings onto the churros when dipped and makes an irresistible combination.

On our way back to the square, I was heckled! I was wearing my Leeds jersey, not knowing that Manchester United had been in Madrid the night before getting beaten by Atletico in the Champions League. A grieving Mancunian saw my jersey and called me out (among other things, as “Yorkshire scum”!), but I just laughed it off.

It was a little harder to laugh off what we found at the Plaza de Sol.

Tent city protest that had been going on for several weeks (and caused the Prime Minister to call for new elections).

A long-term protest camp had been erected there. The prime motivation is the housing affordability crisis in Spain (it’s led to the prime minister calling for a new election), but has embraced a hodge podge of grievances, one of which was, well, us – someone had spray painted “tourists go home!” on the plinth of a monument. Graffiti aside, nobody said or did anything to us as we took in the scene. Heck of a way to orient to your surroundings, though.

For our only full day in Madrid our focus was on art. Our hotel was just down the street from the Prado, which is where we spent a good chunk of our day.

Kelly in front of the Prado. That’s a statue of Velazquez behind her.
A statue of Goya outside the Prado.

The Prado is, of course, full of amazing art (none of which you can take pictures of, unfortunately). It’s collection is fairly narrow, though, focusing largely on Spanish artists from a few-century slice of time. Lots of portraits of dead rich people and more saints and crucifixions than you can shake a stick at.

My two favorite chunks involved more disturbing images. The Prado has a large collection of works by Hieronymus Bosch, who specialized in surreal religious imagery. This includes his famous tryptic, The Garden of Earthly Delights:

Taken from Wikipedia

I particularly liked this owl, who’s face is just like “what the hell have I gotten myself into?”

We’ve all been there, dude.

The Seven Deadly Sins and the Four Last Things is pretty striking, too:

Imagine sitting down to this to play a game of bridge.

The other collection that really struck me are the so-called “Black Paintings” by Goya. They were painted on the walls of his home later in his life and, perhaps, were never intended to be shown to the public. As the name suggests they’re dark and you can feel creeping mortality clinging to them. The most famous of them:

Saturn devouring his son.

The Black Paintings inspired some musical ideas and a story idea, too, so I suspect I’ll return to them over and over in the future.

That evening our focus turned more modern, as we spent some time at the Reina Sofia, which is dedicated to more modern art. It’s full of neat stuff by Picasso, Dali, Miro and others – precisely the stuff I love but that Kelly will roll her eyes at frequently. And they let you take pictures!

“Maternity” by Alberto
“Still Life” by Villa
“The Face of the Great Masturbator” by Dali (couldn’t resist)

The centerpiece of the collections is Picasso’s sprawling mural, Guernica.

“Guernica” by Picasso

It’s even more impactful in person, the black/grey/white palate evocative of the newspaper photographs that first brought the atrocity to the world’s attention.

Cordoba

The next morning we hopped a train to our first Andalusian destination – Cordoba.

Kelly on a Cordoba Street with the bell tower of the Mezquita in the background.

In a way, Cordoba set the template for the rest of our journey. It’s a city with ancient roots, defined by layers of overlapping cultures (Romans, Visigoths, Muslims, Christians) that produce a particular vibe in terms of what the place looks and smells like. It was also our first experience of the really narrow streets in the old town!

A very narrow street (one of many).

We spent the rest of that day walking the streets of the old town, down to the Puerta del Puente, a 16th-century gate to the city, and across the Roman Bridge – which mostly dates from the 8th century.

Kelly beholds the Puerta del Puente
The Roman Bridge with the old town in the background.
Selfie with bridge.

At the other end is the Calahorra Tower, a fortified gate first built in the 14th century. It provided some great views back across the river of the old town.

Yours truly in front of the Calahorra Tower.

Our major site to see in Cordoba was what’s commonly called the “Mezquita,” although technically it is the Mosque-Cathedral of Cordoba. It’s a place where all those layers really come to the fore. But before we made it there, we were shown some other spots from what’s known as the “Jewish Quarter” (even though the Jews were expelled from town in 1391).

Interior of the synagogue.
Statue of Maimonides (rabbi, physician, philosopher), born in Cordoba.

As I said, this led us to the Mezquita.

More arches than a McDonald’s convention!

The site was initially a Catholic church, built by the Visigoths, before it became a mosque after the Muslim conquest. Not just any mosque, either, but a massive one (perhaps the largest in the world at the time). After the Christians retook the city in the middle ages, rather than destroy the mosque and build a cathedral, they built the cathedral right in the middle of the place.

Hard to see, but mosaics from the original Visigoth construction under the current floor.

So you go from views like this, with row upon row of arches and columns:

More arches.
Yup, that’s Jesus.

And then turn the corner and BOOM – cathedral:

Transition into the cathedral space.
Choir stalls along with two massive organs.

It’s an amazing place and cell phone pictures hardly do it justice.

Stone-worker’s mark, “signing” his work hundreds of years ago.

We spent the rest of the day in the old town, popping in here and there.

Church in the Jewish Quarter with a 300-year-old palm tree in the courtyard (growing through the roof).
Bust of a matador famed for dying young in the bullring (so, a loser?).
Art from inside Calahorra Tower.

With that, we were off to Seville . . ..

A few words about . . . food (and wine)

We ate well in Spain. For the most part we didn’t seek out particular places, instead catching meals at small tabernas where we could sit outside and enjoy the city passing by. Kelly fell in love with salmorejo, a very garlic-forward chilled tomato soup (I didn’t think you could have too much garlic – I was wrong!), while my find of the trip was carrilladas or braised pork cheeks (super tender with a wonderful, hearty sauce). We drank very well, too, of course, never had a bad glass of wine (of which there were plenty). I was surprised how wine-focused the place was, to the point where there didn’t appear to be a lot of cocktails and you have the need for wine-bottle-specific trash cans outside a thousand-year old holy site!

Just the wine, now.

Take it away . . . Miles

Miles Davis did an album called Sketches of Spain that’s more orchestral and almost ambient in spots than other stuff I’ve heard of his. The big part of side one is a take on the Adagio movement of Joaquín Rodrigo’s Concecierto de Aranjuez, of which we’ll hear more later.

In Praise of Streaming

When the soccer world turns to an international break, when top-level leagues (and sometimes MLS!) shut down while national teams play, American soccer discourse takes a familiar path. First, there’s the inevitable bitching and moaning about who is called into the national team or who wasn’t (oddly, this is often driven by people who don’t follow the game closely enough to, say, know that certain regular players have been injured for months). Second, there’s talk about how to actually be able to watch the game.

Figuring that out can be more complicated than it should be. The United States plays in friendlies organized by US Soccer, regional competitions and World Cup qualifiers organized by the regional body, CONCACAF, and, of course, the World Cup itself, organized by FIFA. Each organization has its own rights deal when it comes to TV, so in a given year or two the US may play in several different places. Admittedly, it can be frustrating.

It can also lead people to conjure memories of a simpler time that never actually existed. That is, some people wonder why the games played by the national team aren’t on “free” TV, rather than existing on various cable channels or streaming services. Of course, it was never that way (barring rare exceptions, like some World Cup matches), but I suspect many people who grew up in the era of “basic cable,” which included the ESPN family that showed a lot of US soccer at the time, think of that as “free” because it wasn’t something extra, like signing up for a streamlining service.

I thought about that regular complaint when I read this piece by Frances Ryan a while back:

In addition to noting the argument that streaming services are “killing cinema” (not sure I buy that), Ryan essentially argues that streaming actually makes the process of watching stuff more difficult:

the advent of streaming has made watching a movie in your own home more costly, more restricted and often incredibly annoying.

She talks about the ease of taking a “trip to your local DVD shop” where you could rent or even buy whatever you wanted. I find this a very rose-colored version of the before times, akin to the US soccer fans who think games used to be on “free” TV on a regular basis.

I didn’t really get into movies until the mid-1990s when I was in law school (same time I got into soccer, actually). Not that I didn’t go to movies growing up, but I never really sought things out based on reviews or critical buzz. I’d go to the local theater with my friends and see what was there. By the time I was exploring movies – or, hell, let’s use that word “cinema” – there were basically three ways to see something: in a theater, on TV, and via VHS (moving to DVD).

Let’s assume that theater-going was about the same as it is today. But note we’re talking theater going in Charleston, West Virginia. We weren’t exactly a one-theater town or anything (Sutton, where my parents grew up and Ben Potter now lives, had one movie theater and it was all second run), but the choices were limited to mostly mainstream blockbuster stuff. Had I known about independent films or foreign movies, I’d not have had a place to see them (this has changed, thankfully!). Definitely limited choices there.

Then there was TV. We mostly had basic cable when I was young, as I did in law school, which meant watching movies was a matter of what was on and how much it was cut up or bowdlerized from the original. There were pay channels, like HBO, but even then you were stuck with their schedule. Compared to the universe of content available today at the push of a button it’s hard to argue those were “golden days.”

Finally, there was rental, which in those days meant VHS tapes. Certainly, even your garden variety Blockbuster yielded a wider range of movies than the local theater did. I think the first thing I tracked down based on critical buzz in college was Clerks, of which Blockbuster had several copies. Years later, however, when I wanted to see Todd Solondz’s warped meditation on suburbia Happiness I had to go all the way across town to the independent video store (since the movie was unrated). And anything I got from either place had to be driven back within a few days. I thought it was great at the time, but on reflection it sort of sucks.

By comparison, I’ve got at my virtual fingertips a collection of movies (and TV shows) available for streaming larger than I could ever consume. If something new comes out, or I hear about something I’ve missed from years past, I just hop on JustWatch and see where it’s streaming. Is everything available all the time? No. Is everything available on services I have subscribed to? Also no. Is it still more convenient that hopping down to the video store, hoping they have it in the first place, then hoping it’s not already rented by somebody else? Absolutely!

This is not to say that the current streaming universe is perfect. Far from it. I don’t disagree, generally, with Ryan’s complaints in many regards. I just think her comparison is to a utopian past that, for most people, didn’t exist (nostalgia routinely does this to people). Whatever particular pains in the ass streaming brings, it brings a lot of benefits, too.

To return to my initial comments about soccer in the United States. When I first started following soccer back in that same mid-1990s time period, you simply watched what the various TV networks gave you. There was no regular coverage of the big European leagues. You got, maybe, one Champions League game a week, probably date or time shifted (forget the other competitions). The World Cup was pretty robustly covered, but not the Euros or Copa America. And, to be fair, ESPN and the like did pretty well by MLS in the early days, although, again, you were limited to whatever game was on TV at the time.

Thanks to streaming not only can I watch just about any top-flight European game I want, I can dive deeper when necessary. I was able to follow Leeds up from the Championship (and then back down and up again) easily. More time than not I can find Hearts on Paramount+ even though the Scottish Premier League is mostly overlooked. Even domestically, I can track down DC United games given the team has been so dire the past few years nobody would actually put them on TV. Could all this be smoother and cheaper? Of course. But given where we were only a few decades ago, it’s damned near a miracle.

Nostalgia can be a hell of a drug. What we had once was probably pretty good, but it wasn’t perfect. The frustrations and petty annoyances fade and only the good memories remain. Nothing current can compete, since those same things can’t be overlooked. The modern media delivery world ain’t what it could be, but it’s pretty damned good.

What’s to Be Done About VAR?

The World Cup has come and gone (congrats to Spain!) and one of the lingering talking points has been the Video Assistant Referee, aka VAR. VAR is soccer’s version of instant replay that started coming into use in the United States around the mid 1980s (first in the NFL). It was born of the fact that TV audiences (and now audiences on social media) could clearly see when referees made mistakes – surely there’s a way to prevent them in the first place, right?

Sadly, no. VAR, as with any instant replay system promises something – perfection – that no human being can produce. As a result, it’s really only shifted the focus of arguments about refereeing errors. Goodness knows, sports fans love nothing better than arguing and VAR provides plenty of grist for the mill.

This piece at The Ringer by Brian Phillips lays out a few of the most contentious talking points about VAR from the tournament. It highlights (1) Folarin Balogun’s red card during the US match against Bosnia-Herzegovina, which famously included political interference afterwards; (2) the chalking off of a second goal for Egypt against Argentina due to VAR finding an Egyptian foul in the buildup to the goal about 20 seconds earlier; and (3) the sending off of Swiss forward Breel Embolo for a second yellow for diving against Argentina. All this in service of an argument that VAR should simply be scrapped.

Of those, the strongest argument comes out of the Balogun red card. Phillips points out that the way VAR review works effectively leaves officials with a binary choice of keeping the call made on the field by the ref or taking a specific action VAR is entitled to take. In the Balogun example both the original call (no foul at all) and the VAR decision (red card to Balogun) were wrong – it was a foul, and probably a yellow card for Balogun. But because of the way VAR is setup that couldn’t be the final outcome, it was either one wrong call or another. Then, of course, there’s the Trump of it all, which as entirely separate discussion.

The other two, honestly, feel like working back from a result Phillips (and, to be fair, lots of others) just don’t like. Yes, that Egyptian goal was thrilling and it was 20 seconds or so after the foul in question, but the foul is what allowed the counterattack to happen in the first place. If finding the beginning of the “attacking phase of play” means anything it would encompass that. As for Embolo, while there’s a certain bit of the Balogun problem, as once VAR is involved one of two decisions has to be made, I don’t feel they’re both equally wrong (Embolo dove and got caught, already on a yellow card).

I’m not immune to Phillips’ ultimate argument. Certainly my wife is down for ditching VAR completely as the whole process drives her nuts. I will say that for the couple of years the Leeds were in the Championship, England’s second tier where VAR is not used, it was fun not to worry about it. You had to accept there would be wrong calls, obviously wrong in some cases, and just roll with it, though. They tend to balance out over the course of a 46-game season, but that can be hard to remember in the moment, and they may not balance at all in a 3-game group stage at a World Cup.

Ultimately, however, I don’t think getting rid of VAR is a realistic option. There’s simply too much money at stake these days. Imagine a final day six-pointer in the Premier League where whether a goal stands or not will decide which team loses out on millions of dollars the next season. Does anybody really want that? Isn’t there a way to make VAR work a little bit better if we’re going to be stuck with it?

I’ve got a few ideas.

Treat VAR Review Like En Banc Court Review

In my world, appeals in federal court are general decided by three-judge panels, regardless of how many judges actually sit in a particular Circuit Court. If a party doesn’t like the panel’s decision, they can seek review en banc, with the entire court all sitting and deciding the case. It’s rare, but when it happens the original panel decision basically ceases to exist, from a legal standpoint (it’s still in the reporters). The en banc court is not reviewing the panel decision itself, it’s resolving the same issues but on a clean slate.

What does this have to do with VAR? VAR is, effectively, a review of the referee’s decision and not, necessarily, what happened on the field leading up to it. Ultimately it’s not important whether the ref was “right” or “wrong,” what’s important is getting it right, so let’s start with the facts and not the ref’s decision. To that end . . .

Don’t Limit the Remedy

As Phillips points out, the current VAR scheme limits the remedy available during VAR review so that it often comes down to a choice between letting the on-field call stand or changing to a single, particular VAR-approved outcome. For a sport with so many judgement calls – the kind VAR can never solve – that’s a problem.

An American football example: Years ago I was watching a WVU game and, somewhere in the middle of the second quarter, the WVU ballcarrier either crossed the line for a first down or got very very close. It was only second down, so it hardly mattered, but a review was embarked upon. While they ran the footage of the ballcarrier’s knee touching the ground over and over, looking for the right spot, there was a clear foul in the background – an opposing player pulled a WVU player down by the facemask. Seeing that penalty and calling it would have made the minutiae of where the ball ended up moot (it was a first down regardless), but it wasn’t on the approved list of things instant replay could look at.

Once VAR review kicks off, the focus should be on getting it right, regardless of how that comes about. If it means it comes down to a choice between two clearly applicable options, so be it, but if some flexibility is required the process should allow for it. In the Embolo situation it would allow review to wipe away the original Argentine yellow card without necessarily resulting in a second yellow for Embolo. In legal terms, VAR should be about equity, not ticking procedural boxes.

Set a Time Limit

This, I think, is where lots of people get frustrated with the process. VAR (and every other instant replay system) was designed to deal with the “holy shit, how’d the ref miss that?!?” situations, not lead to extensive litigation over every potential minor mistake. To that end, put a clock on the VAR, whether it’s a minute or 30 seconds or whatever. If it can’t be resolved that quickly, it doesn’t need to be resolved.

Embrace Automated Tech Where Possible

Everybody loves goal-line technology. Apparently similar technology in tennis (which Phillips references) is fairly popular, too. Other similar technologies should be embraced wherever possible. At the World Cup a new semi-automated offside system was used and it was fantastic. People still quibble about what the tech measures (which is the fault of FIFA’s laws being written for an earlier age, not VAR) and there are times when there’s more in question than just where body parts are, but in terms of getting basic question right, it worked really well. More like that, please.

Revoke Article 27 and Fix It

Not a VAR issue, precisely, but so long as I’m venting.

Bad as the Balogun red card was, it should have ended with the game itself. Instead, there was political intervention and FIFA’s invocation of Article 27 of its Disciplinary Code, a loophole big enough to drive a two semis crawling slowly uphill through. It allows FIFA, with absolutely no guidance or standards whatsoever, to “decide to fully or partially suspend the implementation of a disciplinary measure.” It had already been utilized prior to the tournament to allow Cristiano Ronaldo to play the first couple of games (as well as some others), but the Balogun thing was particularly egregious.

But who can blame them? If you have the ability to revoke a punishment that’s unreviewable, why not use it to make sure marquee players are still in the tournament and your political friends are appeased? Article 27 needs revoked and replaced with a systemized scheme for reviewing disciplinary decisions (most leagues have them), with standards governing when to step in and suspend them. It will still not be great, but it will be a far sight better than what we’ve got now.

Recognize the Flaws in Human Endeavors

Anthony Taylor, a long-time ref in England’s top flight who had done some games in the World Cup, just announced his retirement. He did so noting that “the pressure is intense and the scrutiny is constant.” This from a man who, in an earlier life, had been a prison guard.

Did Taylor make mistakes over the years? I’m sure he’d agree he did. He’s only human, after all. Antonin Scalia famously wrote in a concurring opinion that “[l]ike other human institutions, courts and juries are not perfect” and you “cannot have a system of criminal punishment without accepting the possibility that someone will be punished mistakenly.” I think he’s right, although we draw widely differing conclusions based on that observation. Regardless, the same is true of any system of officiating a sport. If VAR ultimately promises perfection and can’t deliver on that, how can we expect it of any human being? Perfection in officiating is an illusion and will always be beyond our reach.

None of those are guarantees, of course, but I think they’d help make the VAR system better, which is all we can hope for at this point. But don’t worry – at no time in the future will the sport (or any other) reach the point where fans can’t argue about bad calls.

Thoughts on Rewatching “L.A. Confidential”

Recently, the Rewatchables podcast covered L.A. Confidential, one of my favorites

In that episode they discussed the two failed attempts to build a network TV show out from the movie (which seems like a fool’s errand). The second of those, which only made it so far as a pilot, starred (among others) Walton Goggins as Sgt. Jack Vincennes, the role played by Kevin Spacey (I know) in the movie. I told my wife about this, as she’s a big Goggins fan, and she looked at me puzzled and said that she’d never seen L.A. Confidential.

Naturally, I had to remedy this! A good excuse to revisit a great movie and see if there was anything new to take away from it. Turns out, there was.

Very briefly, L.A. Confidential is the story of three cops in 1950s Los Angeles trying to solve a grizzly mass murder that arises in the wake of a power vacuum in the city’s organized crime ranks. There’s Bud White (Russell Crowe), who’s spun up by abusers of women and used as dumb muscle by superiors. There’s Edmund Exley (Guy Pearce), the political animal “college boy” who has ideals of what the “new” LAPD could be. Then there’s Vincennes, kind of a celebrity cop who works as a consultant on a “Dragnet”-style TV show and has a profitable relationship with the purveyor of one of the local tabloids. They’re all drawn together by a massacre that’s initially written off as the work of young (black) hoods, but winds up going straight to the rot of the city.

What particularly stood out to me this time were the scenes where the three cops talk about why they wanted to become cops.

White’s is a post-coital conversation with Lynn (Oscar-winner Kim Basinger), a high-class call girl who’s boss is definitely involved the city’s corruption, when she asks about a scar on his shoulder. White explains that he got it from his father, when White tried to intervene and stop him from beating on his mother. White’s father tied him to a radiator and beat his mother to death in front of him and then escaped. When Lynn asks if he became a cop to “get even,” White says “maybe” and then that he “used to” like it.

For Exley, it comes during a conversation with Vincennes. He tells the story of how his father (also a cop) was shot and the perpetrator never caught. Exley dubbed the guy “Rollo Tomasi,” just to give a name to the people who get away with it. He wanted to be a cop to go after the people who think they can get away with it (notably, this comes after telling a reporter earlier that it was to “help people”). Exley then asks Vincennes why he wanted to be a cop.

Vincennes – aka “Hollywood Jack” – says he can’t remember anymore.

As a public defender I’m awfully cynical about cops. I see too much bad behavior that goes not just unpunished but rewarded. But it’s worth remembering that all but the worst power trippers in uniform probably got there for noble motives – wanting to help people, protect the vulnerable, and do justice. But even the best intentions don’t mesh well with a system that’s all about the accretion and deployment of power and authority over others.

Not for nothing do none of the three main cops come out of L.A. Confidential in great shape. Vincennes is killed, straight up, by the crooked police captain. White is reduced to a mute, broken man with no future in policing. Even Exley, while he comes out of the whole thing with another promotion where he might actually do some good in the department had to extrajudicially kill the crooked captain to get there (the same one who earlier had chided Exley for not being capable of doing “the right thing” when it came to it).

My wife asked, after the movie was over, how I could like a movie so much that was, after all, about crooked cops. I think the answer is that the movie doesn’t valorize them and it shows the destructive power of a corrupt system that people enter into even with the best of intentions. The moral shouldn’t be that, in the end, Exley did what he had to regardless of the rules. It should be about the toll it took on his soul, his humanity, and his values in the process.

That’s the thing about great movies – you find interesting new ways to think about them with every viewing. Plus, this makes me laugh every time:

2025 – My Year In Movies

Having covered the small screen from 2025, let’s talk about the big one . . .

I had a pretty good 2025 when it came to movies. My wife and I made some effort to get out to the theater to see things on the big screen more than in the past few years, which meant I actually saw some new releases when they were actually new! Of course, the in-theater experience can be a little odd sometimes, so most of what I saw last year was at home.

That included a movie that, while not near my favorite for 2025, has caused me to do a lot of thinking.  That’s the latest from Kathryn Bigelow, A House of Dynamite.

Released on Netflix, it’s the story of a sudden, unexpected nuclear missile launch from somewhere (we never learn where) that kicks the United States’ response plans into action. It plays out in real time (three times over) as the missile heads for Chicago and a response is weighed and (maybe) retaliation launched. The time-loop structure drains some of the tension as it goes around, but I like how each time worked further up the chain of command from information gatherers to strategists and decision makers (ultimately, the president). And while the cut-to-black ending didn’t bother me as much as some people, I thought the couple of coda scenes tacked on afterwards were pointless. Regardless, what this movie did was to send me deep down a rabbit hole of fiction of the nuclear apocalypse, of which I’ll have more to say later.

Several of my favorite movies of 2025 actually came out in 2024, but I only got around to watching them after the start of the year.

That’s how I wound up seeing Anora just before it won Best Picture last year. Yeah, it was that good.

The story of a stripper/hooker who gets swept into the world of the son of a rich Russian oligarch, it’s funny, bawdy, and really sweet in equal measure. Mike Madison carried the movie as the titular character (deserved her Oscar, she did). I kind of expected to be underwhelmed by this, and maybe that’s why it hit me all the harder. I wrote some more about Anora here.

I had a better idea of what to expect from A Different Man, but it still hit pretty hard, too.

It has a simple pitch: a miserably aspiring actor with a disfiguring disease undergoes an experimental therapy to cure it, only to wind up cast in a play about a man with that condition – being advised by another man with the same condition who’s getting along quite well in life. This could have gone a very saccharine “after school special” kind of way, but it didn’t, partly due to Sebastian Stan’s amazing performance. It asks questions of identity, of what the world owes us, and how to deal. Highly recommended.

A more difficult watch, definitely, but just as highly recommended is September 5.

The particular September 5 in this case comes in 1972 at the Summer Olympics in Munich when terrorists attacked the Israeli team. This is not a broad overview of the event – for that see the 1999 documentary One Day in September, which is chilling – but focuses narrowly on how ABC Sports, who were covering the games, reacted to the situation and brought the news of it to the world. It’s very technical and, ultimately, it’s about people confronted with an astounding situation and dealing with it as best they can. Has some resonance today, no?

Home is where I normally watch documentaries – new, old, or otherwise – and 2025 was no exception. A couple were pretty disturbing, while another was uplifting in a way that made its “big screen” adaptation abysmal.

Without a doubt, one of the weirdest and saddest things I saw last year was The Contestant.

A 2023 British documentary about a late 1990s Japanese reality show, it covers the fame (infamy?) of a guy known as Nasubi (meaning “eggplant,” due to the shape of his face – and, yes, that might be where the emoji comes from) who went on a show where he lived in a tiny apartment, by himself, and had to subsist entirely on winnings from magazine sweepstakes competitions. Producers threw in a little bit of food, but he was on his own for the most part. Critically, he thought this would all be edited and broadcast later – only it was shown live (some of it streaming on the nascent internet). The whole thing is a wild indictment of just what you can get people to watch on TV and the impact it might have on the people involved.

Just as sad, but for completely different reasons, was another 2025 Netflix release, The Perfect Neighbor.

It’s the story of a Florida neighborhood fully of playing kids (most of color) and the “perfect neighbor” (a racist white woman) who shot and killed their mother one night. The film is told almost entirely through body camera and dash camera footage from cops, which provides an interesting perspective (although not a completely objective one – don’t be fooled). It mostly plays out as slow motion tragedy (we know from the jump she kills somebody), but it’s really well put together and leaves you feeling like you’ve been on the corner in that neighborhood watching as things slowly simmered and then suddenly exploded.

A much happier outcome is portrayed in Next Goal Wins, a 2014 documentary about the improbable struggles of the American Samoan national soccer team.

Having been blown out by Australia 31-0 in 2001 World Cup Qualifying (a result that caused Australia to switch regions in search of more competitive games), the powers that be hired Thomas Rongen – among whose prior stops included a stretch coaching DC United (1999 Supporter’s Shield and MLS Cup winners!) – to turn things around. Which meant, maybe, winning a game during the next cycle. That happens and its as heart swelling as any game could be, but only because by that time you’re fully invested in the amateurs that make up the team (including a transgender player, highlighting Somoa’s history of more diverse views on gender identity) and Rongen himself (fighting through grief at his daughter’s death). It’s just a great story well told.

Which is more than could be said of the 2023 narrative film of the same name, starring Michael Fassbender as Rongen. I watched it by mistake (they have the same title, I rented it first) and it’s just awful, turning Rongen into a needless villain and smoothing down a lot of interesting angles. Do yourself a favor, stay away from the Hollywood version on this one.

Of course, at home is the only place I could have seen a couple of stone cold classics last year.

I didn’t even know Akira Kurosawa made a movie called High & Low until I found out last year that Spike Lee was doing a remake.

It’s the story of a wealthy businessman (who’s having issues, of course) whose son is kidnapped and he agrees to pay a ransom. Only it’s not his kid, it’s his chauffer’s taken by mistake. Will he do the right thing? That’s the first half of the movie, with the back half a tight police procedural tracking down the kidnapper. It’s wild to see Japanese cops work so selflessly, professionally, and with coordination, versus the usual rule-bending cowboys favored in American movies.

I wrote a bit about High & Low and how Lee’s joint, Highest2Lowest compare here. It’s not the masterpiece the original his, but it’s pretty good with some excellent set pieces.

The other old movie I finally got around to seeing last year was The Great Dictator, Charlie Chaplin’s satire of Hitler and fascism.

Can’t imagine why that felt sadly relevant in 2025 (or 2026).

All that said, I wanted to highlight a couple of great movies I’m very glad I got to see on the big screen.

The first was Sinners, the long-simmering passion project from Ryan Coogler.

This was my favorite new movie I saw in 2025. I was a little suspicious (at one point someone said it was a musical, which, no thanks?) when I first read about it and the effusive praise it got upon release just upped my natural anti-hype reflex. It lived up to it, big time. The world building was completely immersive. The scene where the song in the juke joint turns into a rhapsody across time and culture was amazing. And Michael B. Jordan brought more reality to the one-guy-playing-two-dudes thing than most.

The other great new movie I saw in theaters was Weapons.

It starts with a fabulous premise – what if, one night, all the kids in a particular elementary school class just disappear (technically they run away, but still). The movie does a good job of showing how unsettled the town gets, where blame gets put initially, and the like. The fractured timeline works pretty effectively, so much so that when it lock in for the home stretch it’s kind of disappointing (shockingly hilarious violence excepted). Still, a pretty awesome telling, for the most part. 

But, at the end of the year, it was back to the small screen to see what appears to be the current Best Picture front-runner, One Battle After Another.

This was another one that where my hype reflex kicked in, but it met the challenge, for the most part. I love Boogie Nights and There Will Be Blood so I didn’t find that it reached those heights, but it’s very good. Love the way Di Caprio’s character fails his way through the movie (although he does wind up in the right place when needed), but the supporting cast is just as good (including Chase Infinity, who plays his daughter). Johnny Greenwood’s score is, of course, great. All in all if this kind of “not his best work” Paul Thomas Anderson can make that’s really saying something.

So much for sights and sounds – next week we wind things up with words.

2025 – My Year In Sound

Back with the second installment of my review of 2025 in media. This time, it’s all about sounds, in various forms . . .

Music

Unlike TV, my year in new music in 2025 was pretty limited. That’s probably not the fault of the music world in general (I’ve got several titles scoured from other “Best of” lists waiting for listens) so much as it was me not being into a lot of artists that produced new material last year.

That said, at least there was one gem that came my way, Steven Wilson’s sprawling The Overview.

After a couple of albums exploring more electro-pop territory (not a bad thing, for the most part!), Wilson returned to his widescreen “conceptual rock” roots with this one. Over two side-long hunks of music, Wilson grapples with the “overview effect,” a condition that sometimes hits astronauts when they see the Earth from space and are hit with the insignificance of it all. If that sounds depressing it’s not, particularly if like me you’re not really a spiritual person. There’s some comfort in being galactically insignificant.

This album really came alive for me when I saw him play it live (having dragged my wife along – love you!). Although there was a certain reliance on some backing tracks to get the whole thing out that bug me a little, the playing was all great and the various stylistic sections – from drifty electronics to prog rock workouts and a “day in the life” section with lyrics from Andy Partridge – really flow together. It’s not my favorite album of his, but the more I listen to it the closer it gets.

As for “new to me” stuff for 2025, as it happens the albums that stuck with me most all came out within five years of each other. Let’s work through them chronologically.

The first was Songs from the Wood by Jethro Tull, from 1977.

My Tull collection was pretty much limited to Aqualung and Thick As a Brick, but on the way back from that Steven Wilson concert, in a Half-Price Books, I found a collection of five Tull albums in their own slipcases for about $10 and had to jump on it. Songs from the Wood was the first of those album and my favorite. It reorients Tull toward more of a folky sound, but there’s still some rock and proggy flourishes here and there. That it starts with some great acapella harmonies is a nice hook.

Next up, from 1979, is Supertramp’s Breakfast in America.

Supertramp is frequently referenced as a prog band, but I don’t see it. They’re definitely making arty pop/rock music that was influenced by the fact that bears the influence of prog’s early 70s popularity, but it doesn’t go further than that, for me. Maybe that’s why I like this album better than Crime of the Century, as this one is just full of tightly constructed gems and don’t seem to be trying too hard to be something else. There’s some good snark in the lyrics, too!

Of course, compared to Laurie Anderson’s Big Science, from 1982, Supertramp sounds like a prepacked boy band.

Amazingly, this album, drawn from an eight-hour (!) performance art piece produced a hit (#2 in the UK!), “O, Superman,” which gives you a pretty good indication of what the whole thing is like:

It’s odd, minimalist, electronic in a primitive way. It’s also pretty compelling and an interesting document of the era. Honestly, if the plane’s going down I’d rather have Laurie’s “From the Air” monologue in my ears than the usual platitudes!

Podcasts

My regular collection of podcasts continued to expand in 2025 (for good or for ill), but I wanted to highlighted a few that jumped out at me last year.

The first two serve related purposes of keeping me up to date on my two soccer teams in the UK, Leeds United in England and Hearts of Midlothian in Scotland. The Square Ball covers Leeds, with Hearts Standard covering (you guessed it) Hearts.

I rely on both primarily for post-match commentary. For Leeds it’s much easier these days to watch every game since they’re back in the Premier League, but I enjoy the level of analysis and sarcasm that the guys on The Square Ball bring. The Hearts Standard episodes are more critical, as Hearts are only rarely on TV in the United States (but are becoming more so now they’re top of the table!). Both shows also do episodes about transfer rumors and such that help flesh things out.

My other new favorite listen is, no surprise, another podcast about music, Prog & Progeny.

In this case the “prog” is Marillion keyboard player Mark Kelly and the “progeny” is his daughter, and documentarian in training, Tallulah. Kelly wrote a book about his career a few years ago and that’s been the structure for the podcast, working forward through his life as a musician. So far the reading of things from his book has been broken up by interviews with various folks from his past, including an engineer and (most recently) a roadie, so it’s getting some different perspectives on the band.

That’s it for sounds – a return to visuals next week with my year in movies.

2025 – My Year In TV

It’s January once again, which means it’s time for me to take a quick look back at my favorite things from the year before. A reminder that these posts include both truly new stuff and stuff that was “new to me” from last year. And, as always, I’m talking about personal favorites and don’t argue that any of these are the “best” of their kind. Still, I’d recommend everybody check them out.

With that said, let’s kick things off with the small(er) screen . . .

2025 was a hell of a year for television. Either that or I just did a better job of keeping on top of new series that it really seemed like a hell of a year. In fact, going back over my notes, just about everything that caught my attention in 2025 was actually new.

The Pitt, for example, was just as good as everybody said it was.

We came to it late – in fact, for months all I really knew about it was the legal wrangling over its status as an unauthorized ER sequel. I’m not the hugest fan of medical dramas, but it was hard to ignore all the buzz. We binged it over a weekend once all the eps were dropped and, needless to say, that was a pretty intense couple of days. The series is really good, though, as provided some moments of light and dark humor so it doesn’t feel like crushing dread all the time.

By the time we got to it The Pitt wasn’t a surprise, but Adolescence sure was.

I was sold on the format before I read any real reviews – the story of a teenaged girl’s murder and the hand of similarly-aged boy, told in four single-shot episodes – that I was in. That it touched on crime and the mechanics of the (British) criminal justice system was even better. Each episode was great, with the third episode – a suspect and interrogator (in this situation, a forensic psychologist) bottle episode that reminded me of the classic episode of Homicide – a true standout.

I’ve written previously about how the formats of The Pitt and Adolescence impacted their stories here.

Less formally inventive, but visually dazzling, was Common Side Effects.

Created by (among others) one of the minds behind the equally excellent Scavenger’s Reign, it’s the story of a schlub who discovers a mushroom in South American that has amazing healing properties – but also causes those to take to start seriously tripping balls. The show takes full advantage of the limitless possibilities of animation to demonstrate these freakouts and show a story of corporate corruption and deep paranoia. Can I say, as a public defender, how much I loved the lead pair of cops?

My pleasant surprise for 2025 was Chief of War, the Hawaiian historical drama from (yes) Jason Mamoa.

It was, honestly, a little bit of “what if Shogun, but Hawaii?,” but it looked amazing and it was very cool to have another story like this that centered the indigenous people and culture. It doesn’t quite live up to Shogun in terms of the script or acting, but it’s a solid historical adventure with some big bloody set pieces, not to mention lots of Mamoa running around without a shirt on (if you’re into that kind of thing – my wife is!).

Last of the new stuff that I really enjoyed was Pluribus.

This was another one I was down for the moment I heard that it was from Vince Gilligan, he crafted it for the criminally un-Emmied Rhea Seehorn, and he was returning to sci fi (he wrote for The X-Files, remember). I will admit that I admire Pluribus more than I loved it. Seehorn’s character is hard to take at times (hitting a little too close to home sometimes, too) and, having binged it, I can grasp why people think it’s slow. Still, I think folks who are looking to solve mysteries on the show are doing it wrong – it’s about Carol and her changes (or maybe lack of changes), of which I’ll write more later.

As for “older” stuff (for a certain definition of “older”), the one that really jumped out, from the unusual locale of being a Peacock original, was Hysteria!

From 2024, but set in the suburban 1980s, it’s the tale of a shitty heavy metal power trio trying to get off the ground just around the time of the Satanic Panic. They, naturally, rebrand themselves as Satanic and start to draw a following. I thought the show was really funny and well done (the music was spot on), but ultimately the show didn’t quite know whether it was about the panic or actually something demonic happening. Would have gladly watched more, but it was cancelled after one season.

Other than that, the notable departure for the year was Andor, which wrapped up its second and final season.

Was it a great series in its own right? Yes. Was it the best bit of Star Wars to come down the pike for a long long time? Also yes. Did it suffer from a need to tie into Rogue One and the rest of the established cannon? Unfortunately. Not enough to ruin it or drag it down too much, but it was particularly noticeable as the series came in for landing. Still, the build up was excellent. More like this, please.

That’s it for the small screen – next week, let’s talk tunes.

Highs and Lows

When I found out earlier this year that a new Spike Lee Joint was on the way, I was excited. When I found out it was an adaptation of an Akira Kurosawa film – one I’d not yet seen – I was doubly thrilled. So how does Highest 2 Lowest compare to High and Low? Not as well as it might have, but I kind of think that’s the point. There will be spoilers aplenty!

It’s worth noting that both movies have their roots in a 1950s hard-boiled detective novel, King’s Ransom by Ed McBain.

No, not that McBain. “Ed McBain” was a pen name of Evan Hunter, who also wrote the book The Blackboard Jungle (on which the movie was based) and the screenplay for The Birds. King’s Ransom was part of a series of books dealing with a particular group of cops and tells the story of a wealthy magnate (named King, hence the title) who, while angling to take over his company, learns that his son has been kidnapped. The twist is that the kidnapped kid is actually his driver’s, which leads to a conflict as to whether King will pay the ransom or not.

Neither film, it turns out, is a particularly faithful adaptation of the book for a simple reason – in the book (so far as I can tell – I’ve not actually read it) King decides not to pay the ransom. The plot is entirely taken up in a will he/won’t he. As we’ll see, both movies use the ransom stuff as more of a jumping off point, although they go to entirely different places.

Both movies, though, at least use the same setup as the book. High and Low, which came out in 1963, stars Kurosawa regular Toshiro Mifune in the King role (since the names are basically the same in both movies I’ll refer mostly to actors’ names instead) as an executive leveraged to the hilt in an attempt to take over the shoe company he runs.

In Highest 2 Lowest, by contrast, Denzel Washington plays the aging head of a music label of which he’s trying to regain control.

He’s not in quite as much financial peril as Mifune, but the nature of his business raises bigger concerns (about, for instance, a historical driver of black culture being stripped for parts after a takeover). It’s a subtle difference, but an important one.

The relationship between mogul and driver is quite different, as well. Mifune’s relationship with his driver is purely business and plays out through rigid class distinctions. Their kids play together, but there’s never any forgetting who is the boss and who works for whom. Denzel, by contrast, has a much deeper relationship with his driver (played by Jeffery Wright), one that suggests common roots, if different life paths. The pairing of Denzel and Wright is great and Highest 2 Lowest is often best when it focuses on them, but the deepening of that relationship drains some of the suspense out of whether the ransom will eventually be paid.

Although there’s not really any doubt on that. Beyond the fact that there’s no back half of these movies without the ransom being paid, the fact is there really isn’t much of a moral argument against paying it. Practical, yes, but not moral. To have either Mifune or Denzel hold out would have ruined their characters (or made for very different movies). That said, how the decision gets made is also subtly different. Mifune never decides to “do the right thing” (so to speak) and pay the ransom, but agrees to a police scheme to pay it as part of an operation in which, he’s promised, they’ll get the money back. It’s unclear exactly why Denzel has a change of heart, although getting the money back is also mentioned by the cops he works with, too. I suspect that vagueness is intentional, but it’s a little frustrating.

Where both movies shine, in different ways, is the sequence where the ransom money is actually turned over. Both take place on trains. The kidnapper lures Mifune onto a train where he thinks the handoff will take place, only to be instructed to toss the bag with the money out a window going over a particular bridge. It’s a taut, tense sequence where it looks like everything is spiraling out of control, but actually isn’t. Denzel is likewise lured onto a train, a subway train bound for Yankee Stadium (allowing Spike Lee to indulge in some amusing Red Sox hate). It’s more sprawling than taught, but equally vibrant in a completely different way, accented with chanting Yankees fans and a chase through a Puerto Rican Day parade. Musically this is where Highest 2 Lowest is at its best, both in the propulsive jazz piano score and the sweet Latin fusion of the late Eddie Palmieri and his band (performing for the parade).

It’s here where the movies diverge greatly, leading one to ask whether “adaptation” is the right description for what Highest 2 Lowest is. Which one works better for you will probably come down to what you look for in movies.

In High and Low, once the money is dropped Mifune is almost entirely absent from the rest of the film. The focus shifts to the police who, with the kidnapped kid safely rescued, work on tracking down the kidnapper and the money. There’s some time spent with the kidnapper himself, as well, but we’re mostly with groups of cops trying to track down leads. The driver helps with one, but aside from a couple of quick check ins Mifune is absent. What proceeds is almost like a time capsule from an era were cops were dedicated and incorruptible, going above and beyond. It’s almost like a fairy tale.

Highest 2 Lowest, by contrast, slips into action movie mode. The cops here range from ineffectual to flat out racist and are more wedded to procedure than anything else. When Denzel, who we’ve been told over and over again has the best ears in the business, delivers a pretty damned good clue as to the kidnapper’s identity thanks to them, the cops shrug it off. The dedicated police procedural of Kurosawa’s film instead becomes a kind of buddy movie, with Denzel and Wright teaming up to find the kidnapper and get the money back. This allows Denzel to come face to face with the kidnapper (a rapper played by A$AP Rocky) in a cracking scene in a recording studio that has the rhythm of a rap battle. It also personalizes the motives of the kidnapper, for better or worse.

Oddly, then, both kind of come back together at the end. In High and Low Mifune, who has lost just about everything (some of the money was recovered, but not quickly enough to save his home, much less the corporate takeover), has a final confrontation with the kidnapper in prison, during which the kidnapper explains his motives. Highest 2 Lowest has a similar scene, although Denzel comes into it in a much better position, and it feels a little redundant given the prior confrontation in the recording studio. The motives are also quite different, with Mifune’s tormentor choosing him as an avatar of wealth lording it above the rest of society, while Rocky is bent out of shape at not being recognized specifically by Denzel for his musical talents. Highest 2 Lowest then ladles on a coda showing Denzel’s relaunch in life and business, a stark contrast with High and Low’s decidedly downer ending.

With all that said, does one work better than the other? Like I said, I think that it depends on what you’re looking for. In spite of their common roots, the movies are quite different and it’s unfair to judge Highest 2 Lowest against High and Low in the way you might judge a movie version of a book. They are different things getting at different ideas. And, if anything, the thing they’re least interested in are what they take from King’s Ransom.

Highest 2 Lowest has, for my money, more highs and lows than the prior film. Some scenes – the money drop and chase, Denzel’s initial confrontation with the kidnapper – are electric. Some others are a little sluggish, particularly in the first half. In fact, the critical consensus seems to be that the first half is bad, the second half good. I think that’s overly simplistic – High and Low’s first half skates by on a lot of technical mastery (framing, shot composition, etc.), which kind of overlooks how non-compelling the actual moral dilemma is. Highest 2 Lowest doesn’t get the same break. Highest 2 Lowest also offers the Denzel/Wright pairing, which is unlike anything in the other film. That said, while it does lead to some great work on screen, it also slightly undermines what tension there otherwise could be over whether the ransom is ever going to get paid.

Where High and Low shines is in its broader themes. My understanding is that some critics initially read it as an indictment of capitalism and I definitely get that. This is where Mifune’s business venture being less compelling than Denzel’s pays off because it makes his choice even more stark – he’s going to risk some poor boy’s life for shoes? Additionally, because it ends with Mifune basically stripped of everything it implies that he’s paying a price for not doing the right thing for the right reasons. High and Low also really lives up to its title, shifting from one milieu to the other halfway. Its kidnapper could have targeted any rich guy as a blow against the system.

In the end, I don’t think Highest 2 Lowest is going to supplant High and Low, but I don’t think that was its intent, either. It is, to borrow the musical terminology of the movie, a riff on a common theme. High and Low is a classic for good reason and one of the highlights of Kurosawa’s career. Highest 2 Lowest is pretty good, but I don’t think anybody will think it’s knocking any earlier Lee movies out of his top five or so. It’s definitely worth a watch.